[Top 100 RPG Battle Themes] #1 - Persona 4
Uploader Comments (tomenaki)
Top Comments
-
I'd like to point you to the video description where it clearly says the name of the song. Perhaps you didn't realize the video titles are saying which game these songs are from and not what the songs are called.
-
honestly, if the uploader had like the battle rather than the track, then this would've been even better judgment in my opinion. Game tracks are usually about context, and without the context of the game also being judged, you can say any piece is great, but won't have any meaning.
This track is pretty good by itself, but what makes it amazing is the battle. Of course you'd have to play the game to understand, but that's the beauty of it.
All Comments (258)
-
@lmaonade200 I partially agree with you, the battle does add to it, but I think even by itself it's amazing, one of the best tracks in Persona 4 in my opinion.
-
in all honesty, this song gives you the feeling of a long, arduous battle.
..... which is what Ame-no-murekamo was, REALLY EFFING LONG AND ARDUOUS.
-
This song is powerful and soothing. Passionate for the future, and nostalgic for the journey up until. It's a pure sound of closure, acceptance, and direction. Definitely deserves the #1 spot that it got.
-
I love this song. The tempo is fast, indicating danger and urgency while the melody remains slower, showing the need to keep calm and strategize
-
I wasn't crazy about this song at fist, but it really grew on me. Now I love it.
-
It's always nice to read such comments. I agree 100% with you.
-
It requires a very specific taste to like this song.
-
@tomenaki Thank you! That was very thoughtful.
Can we have a nifty bundle with all the top 100 songs in a nice megaupload package, please?
For what it's worth, I like your selection. It's hard enough to know OF 100 RPG battle themes, but to judge them must be pretty rough. If others didn't like it, they can make their own list.
Ningyosai 5 months ago
@Ningyosai I'll see what I can do. Since this list usually changes, I don't like to do that, but it seems fairly stable now, so I'll give it some thought.
tomenaki 5 months ago
@Ningyosai
Just thought I'd update you. There's a link for all of the songs in the description now if you'd like to have them.
tomenaki 4 months ago
Let me ask you, how did you "judge" these track? Length? Power? Atmosphere? Quality? It's too vague. Naturally others wouldn't agree with you, especially that "atmosphere" part. And people did said: "It sound a lot better if you've played the game". If you can't at least describe how the "atmosphere" is, people wouldn't agree (since, if I'm not wrong, that's what scored the most for you).
Anyway, be careful. I'm afraid what you like isn't the track, but the battle itself.
WallachiaTatari 9 months ago
@WallachiaTatari
Honestly, it's really all about the music for me. There's something deep and just... I can't describe it. It's dark and kind of "crying" throughout, like the song is going through pain. So, it doesn't have anything to do with the battle itself, since I haven't gotten that far in the game. A lot of people think I like the songs because of the games (like FF IX), but this list is all about how much I like the music itself, outside of that. (But I'm not perfect lol)
tomenaki 9 months ago