Why does God punish? By Nouman Ali Khan

877-Why-Islam and WhyIslam.org presents an interview with Nouman Ali Khan. Question: Why did God create people whom He already knew would reject Him and go to hell? Shouldn't God who is All Loving instead not create them so that they won't go through punishment?

Category:

Nonprofits & Activism

Tags:

• Nouman Ali Khan

[dwarriorwithin]

@nyscholartist The moon having borrowed light, the universe expanding, the correct mention of the embryological stages, the water cycle, formation of clouds, the honey bee, the sending of iron from the sky, the formation of milk, the identity in the fingerprint, darkness in the seas, the red rosette nebulae, the unparalleled linguistic style of the Quran, the challenge of the Quran, the ease of memorization, no contradictions in the Quran are just some of the very many reasons of Quran's truth.

[erikachad]

I have evidence for my parents' existence. In the best possible world, good people will do the most good. Wicked people will do the most wickedness. But if you want good people to do wicked things, you're going to need religion.

[nyscholartist]

@dwarriorwithin Hmm. Does being pregnant render a woman incapable of leadership-oriented tasks? The answer is no. There is zero evidence for that. It is not 9 months of pain. It is 9 months of physical changes, some of which involve pain, but most of which are harmless. The act of giving birth takes only a few hours out of those 9 months. And this is all assuming she decides to have children. Frankly, in an overpopulated world, fewer kids would be better. Reason 1: Organised religion: 0.

[dwarriorwithin]

@nyscholartist Hmm..When a woman gets pregnant...And goes through the labour of a child..And is running the affairs of the house at the same time?9 months in pain and you still want her to run the household. Asking a bit too much of the blessed liberal lady...

[dwarriorwithin]

@exmuslimUSAPK If you remain ignorant, you'll learn nothing. That's why I update myself on why I exist even if at all. There is no other explanation for existence better spelled out in the Quran then anywhere else or in any other religious text. All have inconsistencies bar the Quran. That's where we learn who Allah is and what He wants. First understand the Quran then argue about it. Don't go to hate sources. I provided you answers to ur allegations. Refute, accept or ignore

[exmuslimUSAPK]

@dwarriorwithin lol you sure know alot about allah's intentions and actions. almost like hes a human just like us...o yeah thats because hes made up by unlearned men of the distant past. no wonder allah seems so.. so arabic. and zeus seems so greek. and krishna seems so indian...

[dwarriorwithin]

@exmuslimUSAPK Allah will not forgive any shirk now. After the Quran has been sent and the sharia set for mankind.The event in 4:153 relates to the people of Moses and when the full sharia of that time had not been sent. Allah forgave them because at that time he had not set the sharia of shirk being unforgivable. And He was still guiding the people of Moses. Read the Quran in context. It is not my ego. The problem is the truth hurts you.

[dwarriorwithin]

@exmuslimUSAPK If I say..I don't wish to have a son and 'how can I have a son when I have no wife' is no contradiction at all..

[dwarriorwithin]

@exmuslimUSAPK "Wonderful Originator of the heavens and the earth; How can He have a son when He has no consort?"...Reference? Then I'll answer you on this. Seems to be no contradiction at all either. God is saying 'he didn't will to have a son neither did he have any consort'. What's the contradiction in that?? Provide your reference and we'll expound further.

[dwarriorwithin]

@exmuslimUSAPK cont...Whereas 32.4 and 32.5 are talking about Judgement and creation as a whole.God is He who created the heavens and the earth and what between them is in six days, then took over the Throne. You have no protector apart from Him, nor a mediator; so will you not take heed?(4)He directs the Affair from the heaven to the earth, then it goes up to Him in a day whose measure is a thousand years of your counting.(5) Read and quote in context. There is no contradiction.

[dwarriorwithin]

@exmuslimUSAPK Your friend is only God, and His Messenger and the Believers who establish the Prayer and pay the Due-alms, and have bowed down.(55)And whoso makes God, His Messenger and the Believers his friend, surely God's group shall be the victors.(56)O Believers, do not take as friends those who take your religion in mockery and as a sport, from among those who were given the Book before you and the unbelievers; and fear God, if you are Believers.(57) Read in context.

[exmuslimUSAPK]

@exmuslimUSAPK

YES?????

The people of the Book ask thee to cause a book to descend to them from heaven: Indeed they asked Moses for an even greater (miracle), for they said: "Show us Allah in public," but they were dazed for their presumption, with thunder and lightning. Yet they worshipped the calf even after clear signs had come to them; even so we forgave them; and gave Moses manifest proofs of authority

Qur'an 4:153

quran is manmade just like every other religion get over your ego