Hvorostovsky, Gedda "Korobeiniki"
Uploader Comments (Herur22)
Top Comments
-
thumb up for Tetris making you listen to this :D
-
i love this...long live Russia
Video Responses
All Comments (120)
-
YA lyublyu Rossiyu , ya peryeekhala tuda , kogda mne bylo 24 na moyu sobstvennuyu. ya ne zhalyeyu ob etom voobshche.
-
Those 9 people are nazis. What do you expect from criminal bandits.
-
9 People have no heart.
-
and then there was tetris.
-
@ahbahpuh this discussion could go far, it could even be endless knowing that great works that go over our personnal talent can be understood differently differing from people who each have their own ears... Wich is why this music is so loved, we all have our word to say so continue argumenting because your comments could help someone make a better version for you and others so enjoy the music and peace man.
-
Катя Р. это- чудесно.Браво!!!!!!!
-
Катя Р Это-очент хорошо.Ура!!!! Браво!!!
-
Vot uzh pala noch' tumannaya,
Zhdyot udalyy molodets.
Chu, idyot! — prishla zhelannaya,
Prodayot tovar kupets.
K
The lyrics was performed by Hvorostovkiy is better IMO. BTW, Gedda was accompanied with chorus, so any comparison is unfair.
ahbahpuh 1 year ago 9
@ahbahpuh
Unfair to whom?
Herur22 1 year ago
@Herur22, to Hvorostovskiy, chorus usually gives +1 to performance impression compared to chorusless one.
ahbahpuh 1 year ago
@ahbahpuh
Aha, so if I follow your reasoning correctly, the situation is like this: you feel that the second performance is better, but because of the unfair cooperation of the chorus you decided that you like the first one more. That's OK for me, I might only add that the Russian folk songs are usually sung or accompanied by the chorus.
Herur22 1 year ago
@Herur22 Not at all. Gedda's performance on russian folk songs and romances is excellent, but for this song I prefer Hvorostovskiy rendition as is, although Gedda's rendtion stays excellent. The reason is slightly different lyrics.
ahbahpuh 1 year ago
@ahbahpuh
I see.
Herur22 1 year ago