The Sentencing of Socrates
Uploader Comments (ironagetheatre)
Top Comments
-
Socrates... strikes me as a calm person, because he is a philosopher that is really laid back. When I read this, I pictured him speaking, not yelling.. that's just me though I mean, it's not like I was alive in 299BC.
-
Plato did not used such an arrogant and frustrated tone. Socrates was rather ironical and sarcastic by times and he was more the kind to play the silent and the simple than yell - he perceived those manners as part of the rhetoric and Plato rarely depicts his master angry.
All Comments (36)
-
Obviously not, because many atheists fully admit that Jesus existed.
Atheism is a position (or lack thereof) on the existence of God, not the existence of Jesus. Only if Jesus was demonstrated to be God could he be an issue for atheism.
-
@Kinin4 If Jesus had existed, and there was proof, then people would not need atheism. It is because people don't know if he existed that atheism exists.
-
I'll grant you the first part, as I am not learned on the subject.
However, I disagree with the latter; even if Jesus existed, nothing about that would invalidate unbelief/disbelief in his (supposed) claims.
-
@Kinin4 Jesus has not been confirmed as a real figure. If he had, there would be no need for atheism
-
He was a philosopher.
-
This flies in the face of every account I have ever read about Socrates' demeanour.
-
I certainly pictured him speaking softly and calmly. So soft, in fact, that I wondered how he could have been heard speaking his recorded words. This strenuous delivery is not how I would have directed the scene.
-
I normaly think him that way as well, but must bear in mind the Story of the man he almost drowned the told he would teach him when he wanted knowledge more then he wanted the air, and also that Socrates was a veteran of the Peloponesian war, and thus a soldier at one point for Athens agains Sparta
these indicate he had to have a rough side as well
-
my childhood hero
-
@ironagetheatre Socrates was belligerent but belligerence should not be a capital crime.
Socrates was a belligerent figure. most solid historical evidence shows that he was a pushy aggressive individual. It us why he ws so hammered by the "law." He is also a human. Good work on the apology. Calm does not equal rational.
ironagetheatre 2 years ago