Revelation of the Daleks Remastered Scene
Uploader Comments (dwho1994)
Top Comments
-
That was just pure brilliance! I want to swear out loud on how brilliant that was. Just brilliant. I really, really enjoyed that. Your quality of work has vastly improved since your early days of After Effects.
A great re-do of a Dalek story with poor voices and visuals. Top notch mate. Really good. I'd love to see some more of these really long FX re-do's. You should have a go at a compilation next time, with just lots of different randon scenes with new FX put in.
Thumbs up!
-
sexy :D
All Comments (60)
-
@Sang1957 think thats bad? Check out Three shooting a bunch of Ogrons who haven't even attacked him ;)
-
I like how some of the dalek blasts were actually hitting the other daleks rather than keep missing as in the original. Perhaps go further with that. Instead of having them missing each other a lot still at such close range, have all the shots connect with effects to indicate that they are wearing down each other's shielding. That way the daleks dont look like such awful shots, but instead much more powerful because they need to take a lot of damage to go down.
-
That was pretty amazing. I think the grading worked well and most of the effects were great and really added some oomph. A few comments:
The music was a bit too much. Not every scene needs music and you seemed to want to use every single piece of New Who music in a short time, it felt quite off. Tonally as well you had some bombastic music in scenes which were just characters talking, and then the etherial 'Doctors theme' when Colin does the 'shaking the hand' joke.
-
Was not a criticism.
Daleks SHOULD be shooting like drunken duck hunters. It is traditional. ;)
-
AWESOME!!!
Also you seemed to cut off the music as each scene changed. Keep playing the same tracks to help in transition and set tone.
One change I didn't like was the Doctor shooting the dalek with laser rather than ballistics. I know ballistics were a choice on behalf of the director and I do think it adds something to the 'drama' since viewers can identify with the sort of impact damage more.
TFblueshift 3 weeks ago
@TFblueshift I didn't change it to a laser, the flash and laser type sound effect was the dalek eye stalk deactivating, the gun fire is still there
dwho1994 3 weeks ago
@TFblueshift I didn't do the deactivation as well as I could have so I can see how you thought it was a laser because I never intended to replace the original gun fire
dwho1994 3 weeks ago
Even remastered, Daleks are no more accurate than Stormtroopers. :)
Mind you, when you are the master race who cares about targetting...?
BunrakukenIII 3 weeks ago
@BunrakukenIII wasn't much I could do to it considering the are firing at such close range
dwho1994 3 weeks ago
My, but the Doctor is a bit more...aaa....violent than now.
Sang1957 4 months ago
@Sang1957 he is to wimpy these day's, the doctor always use to be known for using violence in self defence but now he has become too soft
dwho1994 4 months ago 4