Arnold Brown's Theory of the Lizzie Borden Case

The late Arnold Brown, author of "Lizzie Borden, the Legend, the Truth, the Final Chapter," believes that Andrew and Abby Borden were murdered by Andrew's illegitimate son William, even though Brown admits he has not proof to this effect.

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• Lizzie
• borden
• Fall
• River
• murder
• hatchet
• true
• crime
• Arnold
• Brown
• Koorey

[MondoLizzie]

the sound works for me. Hit the button next to the go/pause button and see if you can turn it on.

[Englishlass]

@thorn35 I don't believe she was capable of doing it but her half brother William did have the motive and the means.

[Shutterbug1000]

Fabulous theory!!!!!

[FifthContinentMusic]

Get a shave you tosser.

[PancakeSally]

This guy's theory is complete BS . . . Lizzie Borden was anything but this great child. She was a known thief. Andrew Borden had been keeping his bedroom locked because of her. She was extremely jealous of her stepmother and her father was making the stepmother owner of his property. She killed them.

[crochet65]

I agree with agprincess013, people saying they saw this person, but NO one describes seeing blood on the person (killer), blood from the killing of two people with an axe, and this was in day light.

[agprincess013]

@Midnightryder7 The only explanation I have are that the murderer poisioned them first, or killed them more discreetly, and then once they were already dead, they whacked them out of murder when the bloodflow had ceased. Or, they whacked them them jusr hard enough to kill them, then to avoid a big mess, they whacked them more, purely out of anger.

[Midnightryder7]

@agprincess013 You're right!

[agprincess013]

What i dont understand about the case, no matter who killed them, why isnt there blood all over the place? If the murderer really whacked them in the head more than ten times each, the mess would be tremendously larger than just a little pool.

[NFitalianGuy]

This theory is ridiculous.. Why didnt they check up on this mystery bastard ? If the guy wrote a letter confessing, then why not check out his where abouts? The police could find out from Albany if the Man was the actual killer. If Lizzie was going to be written out of the father's will then why would she help a illegitimate son when it would cut her out even further?

[sauroid1]

Have read about this case for decades, and have read most major books about it. I have even been to the house, it looks to be alot smaller in person than in photos. This face comparison between Andrew and William, and the letters to DA Knowlton, leads me to believe that this story is true. There was definately alot of info withheld by Lizzie, Bridget, Uncle John, and Emma at the murder trial. I think that the root of this whole affair had to do with Andrew's money, pure and simple.

[popazz1]

@poosaypirate ,

Oh dear,you managed to crawl from under your rock,did you?! Shame,the maggots must be missing you.Jog on,now.