George Gershwin, concerto in F, Sviatoslav Richter 1993-1/5
Uploader Comments (GiovanniEMB)
Video Responses
All Comments (30)
-
A grim-mouthed Soviet Russian strolls the streets of Manhattan. A wonderful, unique interpretation. Different but interesting and fun to listen to.
-
1 person doesn't like this??? Is this person deaf???
-
I have seen documentation that Rachmaninoff was indeed in the audience at the world premier of the Rhapsody in Blue but I have never read anything about Rachmaninoff attending any other Gershwin premier. Was your statement in error or can you share your source of information? I have wondered if they ever met or had any direct interaction with each other.
-
I found the performance interesting except that the video clip ended well before the movement did. Richter played with a clarity that showed me things I've never heard before in a piece I thought I knew pretty well. That same clarity is also what makes the performance sound not as "American" to me as some. I love clarity in Bach and Mozart but not so much in Debussy or Gershwin.
-
More than any other piece of music, there is a duality to this concerto. It is both a product of the jazz age and a classical piano concerto. Parts or this remind the listener of Rachmaninoff and he was, in fact, in the audience at the premier.
-
Naw, this just doesn't do it for me. Much too stiff - doesn't have an "American feel". Oscar Levant still owns this.
-
@gatomjp damn, you´re right. i grew up with another recording, that was groovy & exciting, unfortunately i don´t have the record any more & don´t know which orchestra played it, damn. it was surely an American orchestra, they "got it" very well.
nothing against Richter & Eschenbach though, they´re great musicians, but i think they´re doing better at European classic music.
-
This music is based on the Charleston rhythm, a wild popular dance of the time. As much as I love Richter only a German could take the swing out of it. Richter and Eschenbach don't "get" this music. They are playing it like it's Grieg.
-
@stackedaktor I can only imagine how hard Richter worked to perfect this piece. To call this an epic fail is really mean.
-
i heard Tzimon Barto and the Nat. Phil conducted by Eschenbach play it live at the Kennedy center last month ...AMAZING!
ringrazio per la spiegazione. In quegli anni anche io inseguivo Richter dovunque era possibile. L'hoconosciuto personalemnte e non credevo avesse affrontato anche Gershwin. Sa anche dove lo ha suonato?
papaia5487 3 years ago
Nel castello di Schwetzingen, a nord-ovest della regione del Baden-Würtenberg.
GiovanniEMB 3 years ago
per me non è richter.
papaia5487 3 years ago
è un disco senza diffusione commerciale che i fortunati uditori si sono presi come ricordo. L'ho ricevuto da cari amici e non c'è dubbio che sia Richter. A dire il vero lo si riconosce dalla sonirità, inoltre soltanto lui poteva permettersi di fare letture così "rilassate" e proporre in una sola sera due concerti per pianoforte e orchestra leggendo dallo spartito!
GiovanniEMB 3 years ago