@XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 exactly thats wat i was tryin to say. there has never been a true Communism state jus a totalitarian dictatorship and a socialist government infrastructure run by one person and one decision. There was a chance for it to exist after Lenin founded the Soviet Union.
@victorhng communism never existed in the world. what you have seen was the fascism from nationalism and capitalism. i dont know what youre trying to gwt at ???
@skipsassy1 The reason Nazism took hold was not due to better economic policies and reforms, it was due to the great depression in 1929, which was also the year in which Gustav Stresemann died (damnit.) The people, naturally, during a depression, blame the government. (Even though it was not the governments fault, it was due to lack of foreign loans and investor confidence due to the depression) so they turned to the extremist parties with their radical ideals in a desperate hope for a change
@skipsassy1 If hitler took power during that period, the country would have been anything but prosperous, he would have dissolved the democratic system (which he did in 1934) and likely caused a whole host of problems, as Hitler at that time believed in military force to take power, which the working class, and most of Germany would not support.
Basically what im saying is that it was the Weimar Republic and Gustav Stresemann who helped Germany recover, and not the Nazi's
@skipsassy1 Sorry but you need to look closely at your history. My major study right now is Germany from 1919 - 1939, and i can safely say that it was NOT the nazis that primarily saved Germany economically. The early years of the Weimar republic, were terribly unstable. There were military coups, and an extreme lack of support for the democracy. Thanks to Gustav Stresemann, the foreign minister, Germany pulled out of economic and social turmoil and experienced stability from 1924-1929
Not true millions still love the Nazis and agreed with their ideas. Sure Hitler made mistakes on the battlefield, but Germany was at its knees at the end of WWI and Hitler pulled them out.
@XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 yea the idea behind communism is not really too evil. it seeks to build a classless society (no bourgeois or lesser class). so basically its a happy little utopia ok. But theres the issue, we need gov't or else there will be chaos (no police or military). i digress i agree there are things the gov't wont tell us and thats also a problem too. So, Stalin should be blamed for ruining USSR. And there is no real communism yet
we have to believe that you dont have to be a "Stalin" or a "Hitler" do be doing cruelty and injustice and paranoid things. USA today is as corrupted as USSR was 20 years ago. Everybody commits crimes
@victorhng ok. there is many ways of seeing things and many truths that are HINDERED and HIDDENED by americans. Stalin should be the one to be blame for any cruelty, not communism. Even if stalin did kill people, you must know that americans are using propaganda to amplify the cases and numbers. the numbers are always lesser and finally, how many people died from USA's evil doing? black racism? native indian extermination? fake war in middle-east? rapes in 1945? nobody are perfect!
@XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 i dunno if communism killed 60 million but Stalin who was very paranoid killed around 25 million of his own people. think its time u start taking a political science class and educate urself instead of worrying about these peoples own self opinions. jus throwin it out there so dont kill the messenger lol
@XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 exactly thats wat i was tryin to say. there has never been a true Communism state jus a totalitarian dictatorship and a socialist government infrastructure run by one person and one decision. There was a chance for it to exist after Lenin founded the Soviet Union.
victorhng 2 days ago
@victorhng communism never existed in the world. what you have seen was the fascism from nationalism and capitalism. i dont know what youre trying to gwt at ???
XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 2 days ago
@skipsassy1 The reason Nazism took hold was not due to better economic policies and reforms, it was due to the great depression in 1929, which was also the year in which Gustav Stresemann died (damnit.) The people, naturally, during a depression, blame the government. (Even though it was not the governments fault, it was due to lack of foreign loans and investor confidence due to the depression) so they turned to the extremist parties with their radical ideals in a desperate hope for a change
kafroflol 5 days ago
@skipsassy1 If hitler took power during that period, the country would have been anything but prosperous, he would have dissolved the democratic system (which he did in 1934) and likely caused a whole host of problems, as Hitler at that time believed in military force to take power, which the working class, and most of Germany would not support.
Basically what im saying is that it was the Weimar Republic and Gustav Stresemann who helped Germany recover, and not the Nazi's
kafroflol 5 days ago
@skipsassy1 Sorry but you need to look closely at your history. My major study right now is Germany from 1919 - 1939, and i can safely say that it was NOT the nazis that primarily saved Germany economically. The early years of the Weimar republic, were terribly unstable. There were military coups, and an extreme lack of support for the democracy. Thanks to Gustav Stresemann, the foreign minister, Germany pulled out of economic and social turmoil and experienced stability from 1924-1929
kafroflol 5 days ago
Not true millions still love the Nazis and agreed with their ideas. Sure Hitler made mistakes on the battlefield, but Germany was at its knees at the end of WWI and Hitler pulled them out.
skipsassy1 1 week ago
@XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 yea the idea behind communism is not really too evil. it seeks to build a classless society (no bourgeois or lesser class). so basically its a happy little utopia ok. But theres the issue, we need gov't or else there will be chaos (no police or military). i digress i agree there are things the gov't wont tell us and thats also a problem too. So, Stalin should be blamed for ruining USSR. And there is no real communism yet
victorhng 1 week ago
we have to believe that you dont have to be a "Stalin" or a "Hitler" do be doing cruelty and injustice and paranoid things. USA today is as corrupted as USSR was 20 years ago. Everybody commits crimes
XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 1 week ago
@victorhng ok. there is many ways of seeing things and many truths that are HINDERED and HIDDENED by americans. Stalin should be the one to be blame for any cruelty, not communism. Even if stalin did kill people, you must know that americans are using propaganda to amplify the cases and numbers. the numbers are always lesser and finally, how many people died from USA's evil doing? black racism? native indian extermination? fake war in middle-east? rapes in 1945? nobody are perfect!
XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 1 week ago
@XxPhoenixHarpyexX2 i dunno if communism killed 60 million but Stalin who was very paranoid killed around 25 million of his own people. think its time u start taking a political science class and educate urself instead of worrying about these peoples own self opinions. jus throwin it out there so dont kill the messenger lol
victorhng 1 week ago