Israel's Right to Build in Jerusalem

Dore Gold spoke at a workshop at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, on December 29, 2009, on the topic of Israeli construction in Jerusalem. Through his analysis of the history of Jerusalem, Gold argues that Israel has full legal and historical rights to build in all parts of Jerusalem.
http://jcpa.org


Israel's forgotten rights in Jerusalem
By Dore Gold

Israel has not yet declared its detailed positions in future talks with the Palestinians, and for understandable reasons. At this point, the government is justly focusing on the Iranian issue, which constitutes an existential threat. This is the context in which Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu conducted his visit in Washington D.C.

However, when the actual talks with the Palestinians are launched, Israel will have to avoid making the basic diplomatic mistake that previous governments have made in defining Israel's primary interests - especially when it comes to Jerusalem. For most of the past two decades, an asymmetry could be observed in how the two parties handled their struggle in the diplomatic sphere. While the Palestinians maintained that their goal was to achieve a Palestinians state whose capital is Jerusalem, most Israeli declarations sufficed with general statements that the goal is peace, or peace and security.

In other words, whereas Israel presented an abstract goal, the Palestinians spoke about a clear and well-defined purpose. As a rule, the side that presents clear objectives is the triumphant one in any political conflict. Little wonder, then, that the contemporary diplomatic discourse is focusing on the Palestinian narrative, and Israel's arguments have been swept aside. Thus the asymmetry between how the Israelis and the Arabs presented their arguments to the world became one of the central factors responsible for the ongoing erosion in Israel's diplomatic status.
This process comes despite the fact that Israel's claims rest on a broad base, and have in the past received solid international recognition, especially when in comes to Jerusalem. In 1967, for example, when the Israel Defense Forces entered East Jerusalem, the Soviet Union's attempt to label Israel as the aggressor failed. The world's leading jurists recognized its superior right to possess Jerusalem in light of the fact that Israel had entered the city in a defensive war. U.S. State Department Legal Advisor Stephen Schwebel, who also headed the International Court of Justice at The Hague, wrote in 1970 that "Israel has better title in the territory that was Palestine, including the whole of Jerusalem, than Jordan and Egypt."

The esteemed British jurist Elihu Lauterpacht expressed a similar view. Such views are significant in international law, as implied in the constitution of the International Court of Justice at The Hague.

Because of the historical circumstances of the Six-Day War, the United Nations Security Council did not insist on a full withdrawal to the 1967 borders, as clearly stated in Resolution 242. Morover, former U.S. ambassador to the UN, Arthur Goldberg, mentioned at one occasion that Resolution 242 did not include Jerusalem, making it of a different status than the West Bank.

In 1994, the U.S. ambassador to the UN, Madeleine Albright, announced at the Security Council that she rejects the assertion that Jerusalem is "occupied Palestinian territory."

The late prime minister Yitzhak Rabin stressed that there was no contradiction between the willingness to hold talks with the Palestinians and the insistence on Israel's legal right to Jerusalem. Two years after his government signed the Oslo Accords, Rabin reiterated in a speech to the Knesset his belief regarding the need to keep Jerusalem united. This position received further backing by a decisive majority in both houses of Congress in 1995.

Two Israeli governments that proposed to divide Jerusalem have come and gone since then, though they never reached a final agreement. Israel need not be bound to the protocols of a failed negotiation.

To protect Jerusalem, Israeli diplomacy must reestablish the unification of the city as a clear national goal, and not abandon the subject of Jerusalem exclusively to Palestinian spokespeople.

Category:

News & Politics

Tags:

• jerusalem
• israel
• dore gold
• barak obama
• UN partition plan
• east Jerusalem
• Har homa
• Neve yaakov
• Pisgat ze'ev
• occupied territory
• British mandate
• league of nations
• United Nations
• international city
• Jewish state arab state
• Tzahal
• IDF
• Ben-Gurion
• Resolution 181
• Partition plan
• Jordan
• Jordanian
• trans-jordan
• Annexation JCPA
• corpus separatum
• west bank
• Resolution 242
• Palestinian Authority
• PA
• 1949 armistice lines
• 1967 border
• Mahmoud Abbas
• Abu Mazen

[mjaisen]

Arabs whos lives in Israel: move to Jordan, the land given to you b´England!

[IamaZionistGoy]

Build Build Build Build Build now and throughout all working days.

Did I forget anything?

[shaharmos]

YES

[EgoNamahaNemoRex]

This is like the standard McGill University Polisci lecture on the Arab-Israel conflict. "Corpus seperatum." lol

[JerrySPsy]

I love how Obama now has a problem with Jews building in Jerusalem!

"Jerusalem will remain the capital of Israel and it must remain undivided.” Barak Obama stated this in a campaign speech to AIPAC. You Tube video “Obama the President of Israhell 1:46

[kentucky9000]

Jerusalam Is in Israel right ? Well the Jewish people can build, tear down do what ever they want in seems to me.  I dont get what all the hoop"ly is all about here. The jewish people are soul sewarts of all of Israel. God Bless Israel

[ShteinbergArts]

impruve your sound !!! u r loosing alot of listeners!

[GanEdenAustralia]

All good. :)

[bocanutz]

well, the problem is now that the only side talking is the one who says jerusalem belongs to arabs. youre right that we shouldn't debate it but i guess loudly expressing the absurdity of it will help.

[mattyhoff]

"You might as well give Jerusalem to the Jews -- it was they who made it famous."

- Winston Churchill's secretary

[Jewishfan]

I don't think Israelis should even discuss their rights to build or not to build in Jerusalem. Just like Americans not discussing if they should build in Washington D.C. or Russians should build in Moscow.

America is screw up everywhere, and its time to tell Americans to mind their own business.