Nightwish - Sleeping Sun [Live Rock Werchter 2008]
Top Comments
All Comments (514)
-
She is getting better live, back when theyn released Dark Passion Play, she was simply bad live... It give some hope for Nightwish that she improved so much in so little time
-
I rly like Anette singing style.
-
I'm sure I would have like Anette a whole lot more if she came before Tarja. And then I would have loved Tarja even more when she replaced her ><; But vice versa is like a total slap in the face o.o;
-
It really is a shame that I will never be able to see my favorite Nightwish songs performed live again.
RIP Nightwish, my once favorite band ='(
-
This is true HARD ROCK! Great voice Anette :) I love both versions, both make my hair stand on end!
-
@ATerribleBeauty10 I agree; what Annette lacks in straight up technical accuracy compared to Tarja, she makes up for it with bucketloads more artistic integrity.
-
WOW....no offense towards Anette but this was just as bad as bad can get. Karaoke does not even fall into play here this was just ear splitting bad this song was so marvelous because of the high notes and emotion tarja put into the song....something Anette has failed to do with every song she has sang there has been no emotion she looks like shes just trying to play around on stage no feelings....
-
@MrNakhrul Private it is.
-
We should move this to private, people will consider us as trolls.
In the link you gave, even the very first note is wrong. As I have said she can't sing it in the original key so every note is different. It would be OK if the structure would be kept.
But it's not. She sings falsly. Random example: in 3:06 - 3:16 almost every note is off key and she's straining like being on death bed.
I wonder what Anette thinks about this '"war". I think she must be kind of frustated not to sing like Tarja, as the success of Nightwish began with her. She knows her voice is not like Tarja's, and i think she tries her best to sing all these "old" songs we used to listen to with Tarja's voice. We can't blame her for trying to do her best ! And it's not her fault if Tarja is no more in Nightwish.
Lyrhiana 3 months ago 35
@metalkingdom100
- "same tempo" - Compare Stargazers with Our Great Divide or Ave Maria. The probability of you being deaf is pretty high.
- "no flexibility" - She sings metal, old school rock, chamber music, folk, church music, even trance. See above the thing about you being deaf.
- Lastly: no, we are not getting bored.
Most of us are listening her since 14 years and appreciating her more every day.
You cannot get bored with the best of the best.
MrNakhrul 2 months ago 10