Narciso Yepes speaks on Forbidden Games Romance
Uploader Comments (drewdavis58)
Top Comments
-
The work was already published before Yepes was even born. And yes: I do mean PUBLISHED... (not some odd manuscript)!!
It was first published as "Estudio para Guitarra" de Rovira by J.A. MEDINA e HIJO in Argentina in 1913; or with complete certainty before 1925. It also appears in the method of Mascaro Reissig (published in Montevideo in 1919), on page 14, with the title "Conocido por Estudio de Rovira". And it appears in the method of Osvaldo Soares (published in 1929 in Brazil).
-
Jack Silver from the Doremi record label, has just recently confirmed that the work "Estudio para guitarra" on one of the cylinders (from the "Viuda de Aramburo" label) featuring guitarists Luis and Ramon Ramirez, made in Madrid sometime between 1897-1901 is none other than... "Romance"!
Video Responses
All Comments (32)
-
No matter who holds the authorship of this piece, the best variation of this is definitely Nguyen The An's: watch?v=APuurr1xKpQ&feature=re
lated -
Details can be found (amongst other sources, including the original mentioned publications) in Francisco Herrera's "Enciclopedia de la Guitarra" and the writing of Isaías Sávio in "Violão e Mestres" (June 1966, São Paulo, Brazil).
-
@naive505 the movie is called "Forbidden Games", "Juegos prohibidos" in Spanish and "Jeux interdits" in french...this movie is sad and cute with this song wonderful "romance anonimo"....
-
What movie Narciso talking about?
LOL! Hey all you conspiracy theorists, tell me how the poor 7-year-old from Lorca got wind of Rubira's Estudio from South America! When you're done, you can dream up an explanation of why Yepes would lie this late in his career about authorship.
So, Simon; Is the author of the cylinder's "Estudio" Rubira? But you said "first published in 1913" whereas you say the cylinder is from 1897-1903. Explanation?
Tell me you didn't create your channel to troll my vid with your anti-Yepes agenda!
drewdavis58 1 year ago
For those who understand Spanish, here is an excellent article:
guitarra (dot) artelinkado (dot) com (slash) guitarra (slash) romance-anonimo (dot) php
Also very interesting is the discussion that follows:
guitarra (dot) artelinkado (dot) com (slash) foros (slash) showthread (dot) php?t=103
ggirino 1 year ago
@ggirino What a pity that Santiago Alvarez was unaware of the existence of the radio interview heard in this video: It would be very interesting to see how he would try to dismiss it. How unfortunate that Yepes left the door open to the kind of speculation and disinformation that is evident in Alvarez's article.
Alvarez claims there is evidence to suggest that the romance existed before Yepes but rightly concludes that the evidence in question is not solid.
Fact is, nothing solid exists.
drewdavis58 1 year ago