Jack's Lament - The All-American Rejects
Top Comments
All Comments (642)
-
I honestly don't care if you don't like this version but it's perfect to me *.*
-
@Nickolas351290 actually this is halloween by marilyn manson is the only song to be feature on the first re-release of the and nightmare revisited. they liked it so much the first time that they just included it on here cause no one could do it better
-
@MrHeadlessWonder Okay you win, it doesn't quite capture the mood. Thanks for debating with me!
-
He sounds like a whiny little kid.
-
@TheBina737 see that's one of the things though this is supposed to be sad. . . lol it's a lament and i mean i maybe judging too harshly because this is my fav song of the whole movie but i felt it didn't capture the mood of the song.
-
@MrHeadlessWonder i respect your opinion, but have to disagree. I love the upbeat sound of the singer's voice. But the timing is a bit off...
-
I like kidnap the santy claws better
-
@fullmetalaang96 i agree that a remake is supposed to sound different and the musical arrangement is very nice but his voice timing and phrasing seem a bit off. his voice is very nasally and it just kinda sounds wrong on some parts
-
@sonicfan11221 YEAH!!! This is my favorite song ON THE ENTIRE CD! I admit it!
-
Marilyn Manson should've done this song as well, he'd have suited it far better. :/



why don't people get it? the point of a remade song isnt to make it sound exactly the same as the original. the purpose is to remake a popular song in a different style. this isnt meant to replace the original song, either. just enjoy it and dont be so passionate that you deny anything but danny elfman. i love him, too, but honestly, its not fair to judge someone else's singing just because your a fan of someone else. who says you can't like this one, too?
fullmetalaang96 3 months ago 138
My house key,which I wear arond my neck, has Jack on it :D
Montanaific001 3 months ago 77