Palestinian Authority TV documentary presents Israel's coastal cities as "Palestine"
Top Comments
All Comments (25)
-
@Conguano they're not the only place Arabs are "indigenous" is the Arabian peninsula, Jews are the indigenous group
-
No one questioned the book when it was released in the US and Joan Peters did 240 TV appearances in 1985. When the book was released in Britain it was blown out of the water by historians. Even in the 1880's most of the 25,000 Jews in Palestine were elderly and came from Europe to die in there ancestral homeland.
"Arabs are not indigenous to that country". Holy Moses where did you get this from? Read David Hirst,'The Gun and the Olive branch' for real facts.
-
@Conguano That particular book is debated among historians. There was a massive influx of Jews the last century. But, there were always jews in that place. Numbers are not interesting. And, there was an influx of arabs as they are not indigenous to that country.
-
Joan Peter's 1984 book 'From Time Immemorial: The Origins of the Arab-Jewish Conflict over Palestine', which claims that Palestinian Arabs came into the land after the Jews had settled it following the First World War has been shown definitively to be a load of rubbish.
Indeed I do know what came after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, the massive immigration of Jews into the land of Palestine.
-
@Conguano Where did you get these "facts" from the Hamas daily? Factories built in those days were in neither Israel nor the occupied territories. They were in British Palestine. You know what came after the downfall of the Ottoman Empire?
-
@berlin10099 A tiny minority of Palestinian Arabs came into the land called Palestine after 1900 whereas the VAST majority of Jews in Israel are descendants of immigrants who came into that land after 1900. The newly arrived Jews ethnically cleansed the native Arabs out of the land. BTW where were these factories you mention, in Israel or in the occupied territories?
-
@Conguano ¨Many people that today call themselves palestinians do not come from "Palestine". Many came from Egypt etc to work in Jewish factories. But, since they are arabs they now took the right to call themselves palestinians. Palestine is Jordan!
-
Palestinians are so far from reality. And one thing is sure, peace is not what they want!
-
Palestinians showing their children where they came from. Showing where their homes, villages and farms were before they were stolen by the Israelis.
You are aware that the Israelis teach their children that the 'West Bank' is Judia/Samaria, is that brainwashing? As I write the Israelis are stealing what's left of it away from the Palestinian Arabs.
BTW Haifa was known as a dye-making center in the third century though is much older than that.
Sorry.
-
Where are all the peace acitvests, why arnt they commenting on this vedio? this is aclear proof why there will never be peace and whos to blame for it. The bastards want the all world.
this shows their pure ignorance to the reality of the situation. Then they yell that Israel won't negotiaate peace deal. Stop brainwashing your citizens. BTW Haifa port has never existed untill Israel built it.
middimar 2 years ago 6
your mom doesnt exist
vadimzdonutube 2 years ago 6