Rick Wakeman - Close to the edge (on piano)
Top Comments
All Comments (206)
-
@MrPinkpound Yeh, great way of putting it - give the music back to the musicians. Excellent comment!
-
Beautiful rendition.
-
Not surprisingly the instru.-based melodic ideas translate to piano better than the vocal ones... well the main verse-form at least (the chorus sounds ok). Seems he only does the verse melody once, and it's (to me) the weakest part... not sure if he does the 'tossed a line around the changes of the summer' part at all. Wonder how many keys he 'modulates' to.. those modulations and changes in dynamics/feel are the best thing about the arrangement, IMO.
-
@RyanYardComposer Do send it to me at superib22@gmail.com when you're done please, I'd love to learn this piece.
-
WONDERFUL.
-
Wonderful piece, as for credit, Wakeman couldn't get credit on any of the early Yes material due to music publishing issues.
-
He played it wrong? I've seen them in concert multiple times and he does it note for note like the album then. The man is a true musician and has the right to re-interpret his music to give it new life. I play various kinds of guitar (badly). I often change a song according to the type of guitar I'm using and the audience I'm playing to.
-
Prime example why YES is too good for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.
Just too good!
Superb.
-
@GusFogle But he played it wrong.
Wonderful - it really is interesting to see how this piece of music is structured. This performance is truly inspiring.
KLezlie 5 months ago 14
@SonicBrunoth Keith and Rik are and always have been good buddies - Rik had Keith on his show on Planet Rock a year ago - there was and is not any rivalry, they are both superb and are individuals who play how they want to and do not give a shit who is best
sparkymachine 7 months ago 13