Hilary & Jackie - Tragedy

*** READ FIRST!!***

I've made a video in two parts. First is Hilary's POV then Jackie's POV.
Finally - I have used THE SAME song for their story but in DIFFERENT version!!!
I love this song SO MUCH... *thud* So can I ask you... Can you tell me which version of it you prefer the most?? I'm very curious :-)

*hugs*

Music by Brandi Carlile.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• hilary
• jackie
• jacqueline
• du
• pre
• cello
• brandi
• carlile

[emilsrud]

This video want me to see the movie SO bad! BTW: The second song was the best... Amazing version... I need to see this movie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you for making this video, it was amazing!!!

[koniczynkaL]

Thank you. The movie is very moving, definately you should see it one day.

[ajikpajik]

What is the name of this song?

[koniczynkaL]

It's called Tragedy by Brandi Carlile.

[patrylamasmala]

I think I can understand what Hillary feels...

It's really sad,both stories,but I had learnt lot from them..

Luck with your piano studies! I'm pianist too, and cellist!

[koniczynkaL]

Yes, of course Hilary can be understand by each woman I guess... You're lucky even more then me playing on two most wonderful instruments on the world!! ^^ Congratulations and greetings.

[AhaBach4Life]

...Where was Daniel Barenboim, during the time of the "familar" affair...?

[kdunkerly1985]

you did a wonderful job!!! obviously, as a cellist, I'm going to go with Cello version... but seriously, either way your video is fabulous.

[hollyfigueroaoreilly]

This is a great video, set to an amazing song by a real, genuine artist (Brandi Carlisle, who I have had the pleasure of meeting and performing with). And what a splendid idea, to use the same song, but the cello version for Jackie's part. Well done! I also read the book, and wish I had done one or the other, but not both. To my mind, they are completely different stories, and I cannot get the factual mistakes of the movie out of my head. The book is incredible and thorough, almost to a fault.

[Kellims313]

Well...I prefer the austin cello version. It's much more tragic (haha), I think, but the guitar version has an amazing harmony that the cello version is missing. I've never seen this movie. It looks good:)

[queldryk]

@koniczynkaL to quote Sir Thomas Beecham (I think) to an orchestral cellist: "Madam, you have between your legs the most magnificent instrument in the world, and all you can do is scratch it" :)

[DCSQueen]

This is an awesome movie. So sad. Anything Ms. Watkins is in is good!

[snootzie78]

I kind of like Jackie's POV compared to Hilary's. As a musician and cellist myself, you get to a certain point where you just can't take it anymore--that you wish your life was normal. I'm sure that when Jackie was at the height of her career, she reached a certain breakdown. Jackie didn't like traveling or being away from home.

[ealducin]

do you think jackeline du pre was that selfish??

at the beggining it seems that hilary is the one jelauos about her sister

i still feel sad and sick when i think about jakcies's desires

and i like more the second version

[fredericfranc]

I was waiting for the Secretary of State to show up and just no go. What happened? And the other lady was she not married to the oil tanker guy?