What's not in the box?

If you find out what's not in the box, you can learn a lot about what is in the box. This is by simply asking questions with only a few options.

Category:

Education

Tags:

• Atheism
• Evidence
• Proof
• Possible
• Logic
• Fallacy
• Reason
• God
• Theism
• Cosmological
• William
• Lane
• Craig
• Religous
• Intolerant

[St00sh13]

You can't narrow down what IS in the box. We don't know what's in the box.

Asking is it NOT NOT all powerful is an unanswerable question, because we don't know if it is all powerful in the first place.

If time and space began to exist, then we have no way of knowing what before even means, never mind what existed before.

He wasn't talking about changing the mind of the disembodied mind. To hold even 1 idea requires time to exist.

Also, if god is infinite, u still have the regress problem.

[ApologeticsBenJoiner]

@St00sh13 My point was that the original video I responded to was pointless. Just because you don't know everything about something doesn't mean you know nothing. If you can know what is not in the box, then the question is which "nots." I can think of many. There would be no before time, but rather an existence beyond time. Just because we don't know everything, doesn't mean we know nothing.

[ApologeticsBenJoiner]

@ApologeticsBenJoiner "To hold even 1 idea requires time to exist." The question is, "Is your assertion really true?" Also, God isn't an infinite regress. God existing beyond time is irrelevant to the issue of moving across an inf. number of days with less than inf. speed.

[CaboDelWabo]

It's quite obvious you fall into the category of people that feel uncomfortable having their beliefs debunked. It's understandable, but instead of justifying utter bs in your mind, step back and try to understand what it is that was said in the video. Understand that your beliefs are personal and you can't prove them to any one and trying to do so, by the looks of this video, will only dig a deeper ditch.

[CaboDelWabo]

You're not even qualified to refute the original argument. You stated absolutely nothing in this entire video. Had you comprehended the original video you would realize that knowing what's NOT in the box in no way proves what IS in the box. You're just talking out of your ass, made evident by the fact that you eyes are shifting around constantly as you search for the next bit of bs you can spew to attempt and refute what was originally stated.

[moldrad]

who are you asking? How do they know? If a mind makes a choice it changes. What one choice? The multi-verse seems to consist of a near infinitely number of either/or choices. Craig back pedals at near infinite speed in debates, He quotes the bible and when called on it says "oh I didn't the biblical God just a timeless changeless eternal mind" or some such. ONce you find and open the box you know what's in it. If you can find god you'll what god is but god will not be outside everything.

[Jiggerj01830]

On the 20 questions, let's change it to asking every question possible: Is it a cat in the box. No. Is it a needle, a plane, a planet - no, no ,no. Once we've discounted everything in the universe, it doesn't prove that a god is in the box. It only proves that the box is empty.

[kickassatron420]

I cannot believe that he made a video as if he were speaking to a two year old and there are STILL morons who cannot comprehend it. it makes me wonder at the future of humanity.

[shortguy257]

@CaboDelWabo ^that.

[shortguy257]

Religion doesn't cause you to do stupid shit, you being a dumbass does lol.

[ogrim99]

So you are asking your neighbour if the thing in the box is immortal?

If somebody was to give you the answer on the question what the thing in the box is not it would mean that he has already discovered what is in the box.