Huwi Shaam Unka Khayal Aa Gaya

"Huwi Shaam Unka Khayaal Aagayaa"

Movie " Mere Humdum Mere Dost
Music : Laxmikant-Pyarelal
Lyrics : Majrooh Sultanpuri
Year 1968
Original Singer : Mohd. Rafi

Dharmendra-ji's favourite song....
---------------------------------
Sung By : Javid Raza

Category:

Music

Tags:

• mohd.
• rafi
• dharmendra
• laxmikant
• pyarelal
• javid
• raza

[peterklus]

I think one must appreciate the good qualities of Javid Bhai's singing on its own merits. Critique him if he is "besura" or if he misses a note somewhere. That would be constructive. But to dismiss him because he is not Rafi Sahab is absurd. No one can sing exactly and precisely like another person. Would you criticise Rafi Sahab if he were to sing a song sung by Pankaj Mullick, just because their voices are different and their interpretation of emotion and expression would be different.?

[graphikamaal]

@peterklus Lovely comment!

[gengarjetty]

good voice, but plz friends dont compare to mohd rafi..

[coolwirelessinc]

you call this voice my god i miss Mohammad rafi

[MrRagbag]

Well done. It is a great effort to sing a song of the legendary Rafi Saab with a difficult tune.

[bobitepal]

kya bolu maei

bs tham jane jaesa lg rha hai

[FromPakLand]

Nudism has taken over bollywood and the art of yore has disappeared. But the bollywood of 50s, 60s, 70s and 80s will keep ruling the hearts. Not to mention the cellestial voice of great Muhammad Rafi.

[swamykool]

@peterklus

Rafi Sahab is incomparable. But judged in isolation, Javid ji's voice and style is also nice. Nice rendition.

[alisha3574]

@gengarjetty yes friend u r right rafi sahab is not a simple singer whether he is a variety of voices,he cant be compare to oyher yaar ,there is a ntural efeect of echo in his voice which no singer had then or now except mukesh ji.RAFI sahab voice is a mircle not a voice

[mohindraandcompany]

This was the perfect match of Voice and Pictures. ...both Rafi saheb and Dharmendra seems to be ment foe each other, the handsome appearance of Dharmendra with sweet voice of Rafi Saheb...the Maestro lives forever

[peterklus]

Thank you, @graphikamaal.

[peterklus]

With all due respect, I'm surprised that some of the commenters seem to think that once Rafi Sahab sings a song, no one should be allowed to sing it in any way, other than the exact and precise way that he sang the song. Javed Bhai respects Rafi greatly and he is paying tribute with musical talents and qualities of his own. Sangeeta Nerurkar has done a magnificent job singing Saigal songs and she is every bit as good as him, yet her voice is female. What's wrong with that?