Karabakh: Falsification of its History

For more information:
http://www.umd.umich.edu/dept/armenian/sas/bour2.html

About "Tarikh-e Qarabagh"
"[...]The part of [Mirza Jamal Javanshir's "Tarikh-e Qarabagh"] dealing with the struggle between the Javān-šir khans and the Armenian petty princes (meliks) of Qarābāḡ is an especially valuable source, being written by a non-Armenian on the major Armenian presence in the region."
http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/javansir-qarabagi-jamal

More details coming soon...

Category:

Education

Tags:

• nagorno
• nagorny
• karabakh
• history
• historian
• scholar
• population
• karabagh
• qarabağ
• karabağ
• azerbaycan
• azərbaycan
• khamsa
• xəmsə
• meliks
• melik
• melikdoms
• artsakh
• artsax
• arcax
• armenia
• azerbaijan
• george
• bournoutian
• burnutyan
• myth
• myths
• lie
• lies
• bünyadov
• axundov
• middle
• east
• caucasus
• russia
• albania
• arran
• լեռնային
• ղարաբաղ
• արցախ
• խամսա
• մելիք
• մելիքութիւններ
• մելիքություններ
• բուրնության
• բուրնութեան
• Armenian

[Vatancin]

ТTH ARMENİAN "HİSTORİAN" SHOULD BE RECALLED THAT THE TERRİTORY OF HİSTORİCAL KARABAKH İS A TERRİTORY OF ALBANİA WHICH DESCENDANTS AND SUCCESSORS ARE AZERBAİJANİANS, NOT ARMEİANS. AND "HASSAN JALALİAN ESAİ İS THE CATHOLİCOS OF ALBANİA,LEADİNG HİS RACE FROM THE FAMOUS RULER OF ALBANİA OF THE XIII CENTURY - HASSAN JALAL." (AS İT WAS TRANSLATED FROM ANCIENT ARMENIAN LANGUAGE BY T.N.TER-GRIGORIAN).

[Arzive]

@Vatancin And as for your desperate Albanian lie, I have a video on that coming in the near future. I hope you'll watch it and try to debunk the arguments in it with actual arguments, rather than unsupported accusations of lying. Given my track record of arguing with you though, I doubt anything serious will be presented...

[Mr100Azer]

I think this "scientist" should work in nursery school in Armenia for very good salary. Because no one of clever people will believe his fairy tales. Of course, expect armenians themselves.

[Arzive]

@Mr100Azer And what should the Azerbaijani "scientists" who removed the reference to Armenians in those books do? By the way, if you watch my video from @5:10, you'll see the opinion of this Armenian "scientists" is shared by the most prominent third party experts of the region in the world.

[BakuEurovision]

This video is grossly taken out of context, its based on a selection of specific sources and neglection of real historical facts. Also note how the video shows Armenian historians but no Azerbaijani historians. And equally important there are many Armenian historians who agree that today's Karabakh used to be part of Caucasian Albania. This video is a sad results of anti-Azerbaijanism the driving force of Armenian nationalism.

[BakuEurovision]

Also this is typical Armenian character assassination, trying to blackmail and target the reputation of objective writers without going into the history itself! Many Armenian historians and scholars actually confirm that Karabakh Armenians were assimilated from Albanian into Armenian. Also note the Albanian church was absored by Armenian church, all points out to Armenification of Karabakh.

[BakuEurovision]

This is state propaganda. Only Armenian perspectives is shown here, not objective!

[Vatancin]

@Arzive WE DON'T NEED THE OPINION OF ANYBODY, IT IS ENOUGH TO LOOK THROUGH THE PRIMARY SOURCES. EVEN ARMENIAN SOURCES.

[Vatancin]

@Arzive Armenian written history, contrary to your politically falsifications, from the 5-th c to 90th years of XX century has repeatedly claimed that Albanians and Albania both ethnically and geographically were not part of Armenians and Armenia.All my sources were Armenians. YOU WITH YOUR LIES ARE DIRECTLY RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS BLOODY CONFLICT BETWEEN OUR COUNTRIES, FOR DEATHES OF MANY THOUSANDS OF CHILDREN, WOMEN, OLD PEOPLE.

[Vatancin]

@Arzive GIVEN MY TRACK RECORD OF ARGUING WITH YOU I I KNOW THAT DUE TO LACK OF ARQUMENTS YOU WILL GO TO OBSCENITY AND INSULTING.

[Vatancin]

@Arzive ON THE ETHNIC IDENTITY OF ALBANIANS AND THEIR CONFIDENCE IN THE SOVEREIGNTY OF THEIR TERRITORY - ALBANIA- EVIDENCES ANOTHER HISTORIVAL SOURCE - "A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE COUNTRY OF ALBANIA (1702-1722)," OF HASSAN JALALIYAN ESAI - CATHOLICIS OF ALBANIA FROM ALBANIAN RULERS OF THE DYNASTY , WHO COMES FROM THE WELL-KNOWN RULER OF ALBANIA OF THE 12-TH CENTURY - HASAN JALAL. (TRASLATED FROM ANCIENT ARMENIAN LANGUAGE BY T.N.TER-GRIQORYAN,1989, PAGE 35 AND OTHERS).