H. Szeryng Bach Partita 2 Ciaccona part 1
Top Comments
All Comments (75)
-
@srinitaaigaura YES! And yet somehow, Szeryng captures all the sensitivity and color a person can hope for!
-
@violatione without any depth from analysis at the work itself.Where is the respecting to the composers?Where is the respecting to music and art itself?Actually we are living in a poor age and I know what I am saying."One plus one equals two",simply!
-
@violatione For those who don't get the real spirit of Bach's music,have no idea of it's structure and never think about the being of music itself,they can go to so many concerts,having even larger music collections and doing much more comparisons,they'll always aprreciate the wrong ones.Mullova superior then Szeryng?The "violinists" today better then the old masters?This is a joke!Today I only hear the "stars" who are intepreting the works superficially by their own imaginations,
-
This is COLOR ! The sound balance is perfect. In Szeryng I can hear the sound of the lower strings just as cleanly as the upper ones in all those arpeggios. Its opened a new dimension for me to see the complex polyphonic character of Bach's music . These recordings are also of excellent quality.
-
Is this a violin or organ? Man he really plays in typical Baroque style!
-
@violatione You're definitely dealing with a matter of preference. Kremer is a brilliant violinist with a renowned Bach, but Szeryng was as well. Who are we to judge the masters? I feel Szeryng had a remarkable intellectual depth with the Chaconne that is difficult to match. I am also a fan of Kremer, but I cannot say Kremer's Bach blows Szeryng's out of the water. It simply is something that is impossible to judge.
-
and as far as kremer, he is maybe the only recording, in my opinion, that can and probably ever will be able to compare to this.
-
lol at violatione... funny conclusions. listened to mullovas... (in my opinion), NOT BETTER. not with borderline spicatto and too little bow to make the chords speak, even on a fine violin. uh.. in my opinion, lol. i sense none of the line of thought that szeryng has.
-
Secondo me questa è la più bella Ciaccona mai eseguita, con tutto il rispetto degli altri mostri sacri che ci sono cimentati a suonarla! Come eseguiva Bach Szeryng corrispone esattamente al mio modo di sentire la musica di Bach, lo adoro!
Giulio Menichelli
-
what recording is this? (like which cd...date, etc.)
nobody plays bach better than szeryng. he is the best
misha527 3 years ago 24
Szeryng's JS Bach interpretations are so outstanding with added touch of warmth and clearly serve as a benchmark for others.
ViolinistAtHeart 2 years ago 16