Scumback M75 vs Celestion Greenback Heritage

My 2 cts speaker test : Scumback M75 65W vs Celestion Greenback Heritage 20W
Recorded with SM57 with Audacity.
Guitars :
Partstrat with Klein 59 pups
LP clone with Suhr SSH bridge humb
Amps :
Laney Lionheart L20H (EL84 20W)
Laney GH50L (EL34 50W)

Category:

Music

Tags:

• scumback
• m75
• celestion
• greenback
• heritage
• laney
• lionheart
• GH50
• klein
• 59

[acdckisszeppelin]

I wonder how loud you had the amp turned up? I ask because I've played through both of those speakers also and I think they're both great speakers, but the Celestions can only handle 20 watts, the Scumback can handle 65 watts in that version. I notice that when I play loud at band volume or louder the Celestion Heritages will compress quickly and be about to blow if you don't run through at least four of them at one time, whereas the Scumback at loud volumes stays clear, doesn't fart out early

[jonizefox]

@acdckisszeppelin

I'm only a home player, and I cannot play at band volume.

It's rightful that amps and speakers will not sound the same at higher volume. Nevertheless, and even with YT audio compression, the differences in tone and grit are audible.

[supafly1954]

probably should invest in a tuner

[jonizefox]

@supafly1954 Sorry for your ears, I admit there's an issue on my cheap LP screwed neck, G and B strings are often detuned (+ or -). I'd rather invest in a new neck for I guess the nut slot is guilty (I just swapped the nut few days ago, issue remains).

[olcottke]

I like GB at 6:21 vs 6:49

[jonizefox]

@olcottke Me too.

[FuzzMike]

@jonizefox

Nahhh man…the vid is cool. Not everyone is gonna like it. Good job, thank you.

[rbehm]

Give me the Celestions any day.....the webers sound uhh.

[DBAmichael]

Thanks, great demo. I'm preferring the GB's. Scumback highs sound kinda fizzy to me.

[jonizefox]

@patricefrey

Je viens de rejouer sur 3 backtrack sur les 2 amplis . Les propos d'Inmyhands sur DRG sont justes.

je monte le H75....