Olivier Latry Improvisation at National Shrine Pipe Organ (1)
Uploader Comments (a55b47)
Top Comments
-
Thanks for this video ! Extraordinary improvisations....
All Comments (20)
-
Latry can take almost any instrument and make it his to own....and we listeners get a musical blessing every time....!!!
-
@a55b47 I would agree that it is not a Cavaille-Coll (neither is a Cassavant, by the way!), but I am not saying it is inferior, either. In fact, I have heard several organists at a Shrine Recital sating that it is a fine French organ and I agree (I have been to many recitals there). I love this organ second only to the Cathedral (need I say which Cathedral? :-)) organ, if they ever restore it instead of dismantling it!
-
@chamade216 It's curious that so many people focus upon what IS NOT, rather than what IS. Someone posts a video of a particular organist playing a particular instrument, and people feel compelled to comment about other performances and other instruments, which have nothing to do with what is here in this moment. It's a disease of the modern mind. Almost always in the past and the future, almost never in what is here now. Beautiful instrument and performance in a wonderful setting.
-
Overly harsh statement, Chamade. I have a recording of Maurice and Madelline Durufle playing Bach music at the National Shrine. These two organs are incomparible in power and beauty, Cavaille-Coll notwithstanding. I want to worship here before I die.
-
best
-
The Impro is WONDERFUL, but the Choir is not so good ;)
-
@chamade216 I have that CD.
-
I see, you're right. I became too sensitive to organ sound which is not from Notre-Dame or St.Ouen. I heard this on ND organ first. By the way do you know if the sheetmusic is availale yet?
This sounds much better in Notre Dame in the new Hortus CD called Salve Regina. This organ is nothing compared to Notre-Dame:-)
chamade216 2 years ago
Well, Chamade, I don't think anyone would ever MAKE the claim that a Moller would sound better playing French music than a (sort of) Cavaille-Coll. Unfortunately, M. Cavaille-Coll didn't build many instruments on our side of the Atlantic -- so we go with what we've got ;-) For what it's worth, I've seen a lot of comments on other YT videos that maintain that the current ND instrument is a pale shadow of what it was before M. Cochereau got his hands on it. I take no position on that.
a55b47 2 years ago 4
This really puts the organ's voicing to the test. By the way, waht do you mean by 157/172? Why is there a difference of 15 ranks? Sorry. I am new to the King of Instruments.
passacaglia28 2 years ago
157 stop tabs controlling 172 ranks of pipes. Some tabs (the Mixtures & the Voix Celeste, for instance) control more than one rank.
a55b47 2 years ago