Manyu Suktam from Rg vEda
Uploader Comments (yadbhavishya)
All Comments (8)
-
ok. You now think that the there is NO incorrect intonation of any syllable, contrary to what you previously said. (hmm..but thats ok!).
Secondly, your choice of your words, "intensity", "amplitude", "bar markers", is completely alien to me. Please explain your point in terms of udaatta, anudaatta and svarita. Also, regarding the rules of pronounciation, please quote the relevant sutra from paniniya shiksha, so that you can support your point from shaastraic POV.
-
@dandakaaranya it's not the pronounciation.. its the intensity and amplitude of the voice..... for example... when he says manyurindroho... its needs a very long pronounciation of "dro" with moderate intensity...and the next "ho" must be sharp but very intense... hope this helps.. u can get sanskrit renderings of the sukta on the net... with bar markers aa markers of type of intonation...try it...jai sreeram!!
-
@dbzfred I have the highest respect for challakere brothers. They are known for their swara shuddhi. However, I dont understand how it applies to this rendering.
Can you give an example of an incorrect intonation of a syllable in this rendering?
-
@yadbhavishya reciting of the vedas needs and requires three kinds of shuddhi..
akshara shuddhi.. the correct pronounciation...
matra shuddhi..the correct duration of chanting each syllable..
swara shuddhi..the correct intonation of each syllable..
the above recitation lacks the third...
with proper recital vedas sound very powerful..
watch this.. /watch?v=_ikKPiCK53s&feature=r
elated hope it helps.. vedas give the right results when recited with shuddhi..
-
Powerful and wonderful rendering
reciting needs to be powerful. This is a very very powerful sooktam and it demands a much better rendering...
sunilanandatheertha 8 months ago
@sunilanandatheertha
With all due respects to your knowledge, what is powerful rendering? If you could please explain.
Also, when you say powerful and 'demands much more', how do you explain - "ऋचो अक्षरे परमे व्योमन्यस्मिन देवा अधि विश्वे निषेधुः" ? Is not every akshara of vedam the same?
For a change, how about paying attention to 'correctness'?
Is the power not in the meaning? Do you not agree?
yadbhavishya 8 months ago