John Cage - Water Walk
Top Comments
All Comments (1,062)
-
/watch?v=tUh7xpoSjL0
-
I actually really liked the fact that the audience laughed. I consider this somewhat an extension of the "Theater of the Absurd" from a few decades before; Samuel Beckett's plays were found fairly humorous (and I find them fairly funny too). There's something about the chaos, about the deconstruction of art down to its simplest forms and its randomness that seems to be appealing. In Beckett's play there are many random lines and moments that have reminded me of a lot of humor in sitcoms today.
-
@ThatSalvadoreanGuy I like it, it would be naïve to assume they wouldn't laugh.
-
Despite your best efforts, by calling the audience "simpletons" and disliking their laughter, you probably understand Cage less than this audience did. He intended that laughter. It was in fact part of the music. It was a random, ever-changing element, something that Cage found essential.
-
Humor is created when one is subjected to the happily unexpected, and thus this act, whether he intended it or not, was hilarious.
Just as a good punch line is always one you didn't see coming, not a single movement in this entire performance could be predicted or fully explained. The audience was laughing because this act had all the workings of something brilliantly funny, and was delivered so dryly and seriously that it intensified this tenfold.
-
@ThatSalvadoreanGuy i like how he took it, such a good soul
-
@tykun101 Just look at John's face while he is being introduced, and listen to the host's tone. From my reading, it seems like Mr. Cage would like to be taken a bit more seriously, but the host plays the role of treating him like a clown by subtly mocking his "music," and frequently interrupting him. I'm totally down for zany, but also for heartfelt. I feel like the best combination comes when there is an initial serious approach to ridiculous material. Respect yields more joy than sarcasm. :D
-
He's sounds like the Brain, from Animaniacs.
I can't stand the audience laughing
ThatSalvadoreanGuy 7 months ago 66
after listening to this i went to make myself some tea, and i suddenly noticed all those little sounds - the water boiling, the sugar hitting the bottom of the glass. I noticed that they have a rhythm to them. that was very enjoyable.
it made me understand something - whether or not this is music is a question of semantics. foremost it is an admirable artistic performance.
mkotisrael 5 months ago 23