Documentation of Samuel Beckett's Not I
Uploader Comments (Vime)
All Comments (8)
-
@erniehead thats funny.. but IRRELEVANT
-
Interesting interpretation. It feels like she's reading this instead of recalling the speech.
Although I don't remember Beckett writing in his description that the speaker should have two giant zits on her chin.
-
@Vime sam isnt a fan of 'interpretations'. he isnt even a fan of acting.
-
i'm not saying this version is bad or not worth a ganders. but if a student was writing a paper on this play, this is def not the version they should base there view upon. in a way it may even be clever for making the work become something very different from what the original intention was meant to be. i shall watch it and try not to be bias
-
i am very recent to beckett, aware of him previously, but never stopped to ponder work, but from what i can gather works of this ilk are about internal dialogue and the obscure tangental meanderings of the messy human mind, so i can fully go along with directors who set beckett at a 100mph, as the mind flies, for that reason i feel this version misses much of the point of what he is aiming for. maybe an ordered mind thinks at this speed, but this is not the ramblings of a level headed individual
-
No where NEAR Billie Whitelaw's version!
And excuse I if I trust that one best, since Beckett himself directed her and told her exactly how to do it.
-
That's an interesting version!
Those of you who like this video (and even those who do not) are invited to watch my picture interpretation of this monologue: No, Nope, Nottt!
nigulat
Why so slow?
Bigworld 2 years ago
When reading the play, and hearing it in my head, I always experienced it that way.
Unlike most versions, which suggest a manic inner dialogue, I hear a desperate, crawling, emotionally vacant voice. Someone dead inside, medicated; stumbling, plodding, lost in her own mind, not racing through it.
I find the slow, cold recitation to be hypnotic. The despair in the piece becomes oppressive and grinding in a reading like this.
Vime 2 years ago