Top Comments
All Comments (25)
-
@tanji123 went to one of Gk's shows a few years ago, he laughed that barry manilow payed for his house, and denis waterman payed to furnish it. So your right, he did appreciate it lol
-
@hobbily I don't think Kenny is missing the passion, I think his version is pasionate in a different way. Kenny wrote about the story of a struggling musicain and Manilow took the song and turned it into a song about a persons struggle through life. Both versions are great!
-
I am a big fan of both Gerard and Barry and love what both have done with this song, both are great artists and I think that very few in the history of popular music have equaled their status.
-
both Gerard's and Barry's versions are great. But hats off to Gerard for the origional music which I believe makes this song a priceless classic... Thanks gerard From one musician to another. . . .Thanks you inspire me.
-
Don't forget Gerard got royalties for Barry's version and probablly made a bit of money. Also he got noticed more than he would have. So maybe Barry did him a favor. Barry did Rupert Holmes "studio musician" on his Live album and Rupert was always appreciative of that. That was before " pina colada". But he got paid and I'm sure that is always helpful to unknown musicians. Either way, I think both versions are good.
-
Barry's version all the way xx this is good but Barry put's so much passion into his songs , thats missing here
-
Just listened to Manilow's version again.........and prefer it. He sings it for everyman. Kenny sings it for musicians exclusively.
-
Great tune! Very American sentiment, a Brit would find it too schmaltzy. Manilow sings a better version - just!
-
Sheer class. What a talent.
-
Well done Gerard,fantastic It never leaves you mate
This is how Gerard wrote it before Barry screwed it up. Three cheers for Mr. Kenny.
herpur7 1 year ago 3
A song written by one songwriter about the struggle for recognition by all songwriters and far superior to the re-written dross of Barry Manilow's.
Thanks Gerard.
5ersgone 1 year ago 2