Our Brochures Are Not Blank, Ten Point Vision Finalist
Top Comments
All Comments (35)
-
@StickInMudd Something like [youtube: How New Moon should have ended by jayandsilentvic] would be great about the voices. Silly but fun and interesting. I made the animation, but all the voices made by a friend who is not an actor and he tried it for 1st time.
-
@StickInMudd I could do a better job with the animation and yes the voices were quite bad. Actually I might go and do an anti-religion animation!
-
I'm optimistic and cynical. :D
-
What if the R.D. Foundation gave an annual humor award, to honor shows like Mr. Deity and web comics like Jesus and Mo?
-
@Velox415 Okay, thanks for your critique. Just to ask for future reference. If this cartoon was not in this competition, and it was just a random youTube video, would the voice still be annoying to you, or would it be more acceptable within the cartoon medium?
Just asking so I can improve my style.
-
@grumhelden Thanks for your input. But I disagree that this competition was about sugar coating the issues. It had a very specific guideline; follow the ten point vision, and I did that.
I don't want to seem argumentative or like I'm being an ass, because I'm still surprised this even got to the finals. I'm just hoping to get some feedback for future reference.
Cheers!
-
@StickInMudd Thanks for the reply, I meant no personal angle, just a general observation that, as we say in scots "ye catch mair flies wi sugar than sh*te".
-
@StickInMudd I appreciate the effort that went into this, but the voice of the old guy is very whiny and it got on my nerves very quickly. I think maybe if it wasn't so nasal or something it would have been better.
-
@XxAmericanLedxX Thank you!
-
@Airmanf7 Thank you! It seems that there is a lot of people who didn't like the voices. Though my regular voice is the guy with the brochure, so hopefully they are not dising on that one!
I guess cartoon voices are not well recieved on richardawkinsdotnet.
those voices killed it.
sg8man 1 month ago 31
Any need for the moronic voices?
earlofainsdale 1 month ago 30