Nearer, My God, to Thee (Horbury) — Choir of Wells Cathedral
Uploader Comments (1finch2finch)
All Comments (14)
-
We will never know which song was really sung on the Titanic.
-
I prefer Horbury over Bethany.
-
Put on earphones/headphones.
-
This is actually the version of Nearer My God To Thee that the Titanic band could have played while the ship was sinking. The only other version of Nearer My God To Thee the band could have played was Propior Duo, because these are the only two versions the band knew.
-
@therealjoebloggs I guess that has ABSOLUTELY nothing to do with the fact that "Bethany" happens to be the most popular and recognizable version...everywhere except in Great Britain.
That's why Cameron chose it for his "Titanic," but "Horbury" for his "Ghosts of the Abyss."
-
@TheTarget1980 And yet "Bethany" persists; as John Ford opined in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, "Print the legend."
Uncanny. I just finished a poem about the love of God, which uses the image of a wave rolling over another wave, and right after I saved it, I clicked to watch this video.
maartendas 6 months ago 2
@maartendas You must be well tuned-in with the world today.
1finch2finch 6 months ago
Unfortunately your version here is a little to "silent", is it possible to reload it lauther?
TheTarget1980 7 months ago
@TheTarget1980 I haven't done anything to the sound of the original file, so I, unfortunately, amn't sure why it should sound so quiet. If I fuss with the volume in an audio programme, the sound will get 'fuzzy' with white noise, and the quality will be compromised. If you have any suggestions, though, for how to increase the volume without compromising quality, I'd be glad to re-upload.
1finch2finch 6 months ago
"Horbury" was more popular in England, so Wallace Hartley, bandleader of the titanic, as an englishmen, would have played this. And if i remember correctly, an old survivor, Eva HArt, sings this version when she remembered speaking about titanics last song.
TheTarget1980 7 months ago
@TheTarget1980 There's still a bit of confusion, I think, because Hartley was a Methodist and would have been familiar with the 'Propior Deo' tune in addition to 'Horbury', which, as you've said, is certainly more common than any of the others in the Anglican Church. At least we can be quite sure that 'Bethany', no matter what James Cameron's film might lead us to believe, is almost certainly wrong!
1finch2finch 7 months ago 3