Is this really bach? I dont think so,... I searched a long time and think bach would never play like you. Its your very own interpretation. Where did you study? If I could give you a little tip. Listen to a accordion interpretation!
@OrgueJeanVALLA if you really are an amateur, then I have to pay my greatest respect. Well, I study music and physics by the way =) but thats not the point. I asked some teachers today and I have to say that im very sorry for my comment. You're right, Bach is very free to play^^ okey, there are interpretations ... ehehem ... but no, I think you did great job and i cants recommend a good accordeon interpretation. nothing on youtube... :P its nice to see that you enjoy music. great piece!
@DreamCrew2007 Thank you, nothing matter. Music is like wine : somebody can hate and another person can enjoy the same pièce or interpretation of a piece of music. You tube is for me a purpose to improve myself someone may appreciate and another don't like. In this pièce, there is some mistakes, but I try to give what I can, without skip or falsification.
Is this really bach? I dont think so,... I searched a long time and think bach would never play like you. Its your very own interpretation. Where did you study? If I could give you a little tip. Listen to a accordion interpretation!
DreamCrew2007 8 months ago
@DreamCrew2007 Thank you for your kind comment. I am just an amateur, and I am largely self taught.
Yes Its one of my owns interpretation, and nobody can say how Bach could play pipe organ.
Some peoples think also that Bach was not the composer of this piece.
I think also that listen an accordion interpretation should very benefit. Do you have a reference ?
OrgueJeanVALLA 8 months ago
@OrgueJeanVALLA if you really are an amateur, then I have to pay my greatest respect. Well, I study music and physics by the way =) but thats not the point. I asked some teachers today and I have to say that im very sorry for my comment. You're right, Bach is very free to play^^ okey, there are interpretations ... ehehem ... but no, I think you did great job and i cants recommend a good accordeon interpretation. nothing on youtube... :P its nice to see that you enjoy music. great piece!
DreamCrew2007 8 months ago
@DreamCrew2007 Thank you, nothing matter. Music is like wine : somebody can hate and another person can enjoy the same pièce or interpretation of a piece of music. You tube is for me a purpose to improve myself someone may appreciate and another don't like. In this pièce, there is some mistakes, but I try to give what I can, without skip or falsification.
OrgueJeanVALLA 8 months ago
Merci... j'y suis sensible, mais tout le mérite en revient à Bach.
OrgueJeanVALLA 1 year ago