Pirate Jenny
Uploader Comments (elphabastav)
Top Comments
-
Amazing!!
I love your anger and your enthusiasm.
Definitely one of my favourite renditions of the song.
-
Those fuckers laugh because the song is funny ... black, grim, violent and very, very funny.
It is about a scullery maid fantasizing about violently killing everyone she has to do menial work for ...if that's not funny, you just don't get Brecht'd dark humour.
All Comments (17)
-
wow.
the original still is the best. german ROCKS!
-
Really great! I love finding different renditions of this song and seeing how each singer interprets it.
Where did you find the Hebrew translation? I've found French and Italian translations online, but never a Hebrew one.
-
sehr gut, ki-tow :-)
-
wow
-
Awesome rendition of a beautiful song. I can see that you have a future in the musical theatre business.
-
Nice job!
why do those fuckers laugh?
Crosell 2 years ago
Cause they were too stupid to undersand this isn't funny at all? :)
elphabastav 2 years ago 2
too theatrical.... not what brecht meant at all...sorry for negative comments but just look at Gisela May
POET444 2 years ago
I have to disagree. Brecht, with his whole idea of theater as a format that should awaken your mind and not your heart, always tried to make his productions as "artificial" as possible so that the audience wouldn't relate to them emotionaly. Many of his tricks were extremely theaterical - stuff like have the lighting devices show or having written signs to announce where the play is taking place, whatever made it theaterical and un-realistic.
So considering that, I think he would like this :)
elphabastav 2 years ago
She's great and very pretty. I like this song alot but I've only heard it in English and German. I bet it would sound pretty good in Yiddish. Is this girl a university student?
danawillis 3 years ago
And I've never heard a Yiddish version of it, but singing it in Hebrew was fun :)
I did that for a competition in my college in Israel, I left that school in the middle of freshman year and right now I'm studying Musical Theatre in NYC, I might do this song again here, but obviously in English :)
I think I pretty much covered all your questions... And thank you again for the encouraging comment!
elphabastav 3 years ago