Tekki Shodan Shotokan Kata
Uploader Comments (shotokanunleashed)
All Comments (44)
-
Nice
-
@WestBfella Care to give me an example? How can you say he has good knowledge of the kata, what is the basis of your remark? Can you name one JKA life member? Seeing as how that only takes place in Japan and that it is a private matter, how do you know? Do they have a tatoo? What is good about his stances, an example? Do strong techniques indicate knowledge? Is it possible that you really do not understand original karate, the JKA certainly doesn't?
-
muy bueno
-
nice performances on the tekki shodan kata
-
@IEKUKATAKA Geez, know-it-all.
-
@IEKUKATAKA I disagree - I think this kata shows many instances of bunkai. His attacks are consise and he has a god knowledge of this kata. His stance is good and his attacks are strong. His head moves with a sense of purpose - I have seen many a poor kata come from a JKA life member. This kata in my humble opinion is very good
-
Looks nice.
That's my absolute favourite Kata, I love to compare the way everyone does this Kata. It really is one of those things that shows how a person is. One of my friend does this Kata very nice, gotta love it.
-
Good kime for what? Speed for what? Control of what? I see no bunkai at all in this kata. Kata represent yakusoku kumite or some persons vision of what is happening. It is supposed to look like a fight. That being the case, what is this guy doing? The JKA made a big mistake when they changed established kata and assigned no rational bunkai. How they grade kata is nonsense. Before you go into lunar orbit, I am a JKA life member trained in Japan. I should know.
-
If you learned it today it's gonna take you a few years to do it almost as good as this guy does. This is a very good execution of Tekki Shodan.
-
very nice, good kime, good speed, good control!
Motobu NEVER practised Tekki- he studied the Naihanchi kata. The movements of the Shotokan version are quite different from the Okinawan kata which Motobu practised. As Funakoshi was not a fan of Motobu Sensei, I would imagine that both would spin in their graves were they to know that you have likened their systems.
I would ask that you review the history of Motobu Choki as he was not the "thug" that many have made him out to be.
Yasaguri 4 years ago
Yasaguri, thanks for the comment, I never said Motobu practiced Tekki. I haven't likened their systems intentionally, isn't it a fact that tekki came from naihanchi?
I will do as you say and review the history of Motobu Choki.
shotokanunleashed 4 years ago