Yes - Close To The Edge with classical orchestra (Symphonic Music of Yes)
Uploader Comments (tuktuktok)
Top Comments
-
Close to the Edge, (as Recorded by Yes) is simply one of the Greatest pieces of Music ever Recorded.
-
wow must have this
All Comments (29)
-
this fusion is for people that liked the album Magnification, because it sounds a little bit like it. I liked the Magnification, i think this variant of the song sounds a little bit less Prog and much more movie soundtrack. It's the point of view, and what were you looking for that changes the whole song :)
-
Yes OK. Classical music OK. But this fusion: no. Never use regular rock drums in a classical piece!
-
Fuck yeah! Even more pompous than regular Yes! :-)
-
It's the timing that destroys the experience.
-
@merloon I see what you mean. Most of the orchestra is devoted to merely portraying the lyrical notes, rather than enhancing them. For example, at around 1:10 when they move into the words for The Solid Time of Change, the strings could hold the lyrics, while woodwinds and/or brass double-time in a higher range over top. Or something. It justs feels flat for such an ambitious original as this was back in '72.
-
very similar to the original, when the idea of these things is to re-arrange them. anyway, i always had this version and i enjoy it (differently) but i do
-
FANTASTIC! Loved it!
-
de putamrrrrrrrrrrrr
-
Mmmm, soup...
-
The best thing about this is Bruford's drumming. If you're a fan of his drumming in Yes, it's quite a treat. Beyond that, meh..



I love orchestral music. I REALLY love Close to the Edge.
I hated this.
Not sure why; maybe it was the arrangement, but I felt like I was in an elevator for seven minutes. I needed a shower to get the muzak off me. Gut reaction: I'd love to hear John Williams take a shot at arranging and conducting CTTE for orchestra. Has to be better than this torturefest.
merloon 2 years ago
I like this version very much but can in a way understand what you mean. The mixing and perhaps the whole arrangement could have been better. They should have had a little more balls. Like you said, more Williams style, that is more Yes. Also, the song is also insultingly short.
tuktuktok 2 years ago