Lisbon Treaty (full version) Ireland & the abortion question
Loading...
Loading...
4:09
Kathy Ireland on Abortionby andymmmkay16,967 views- 0:26
Abortion Protest in Irelandby gabinchis2,848 views
- 9:33
Ireland vote NO to LISBON 2 THE REAL STORY OF EUROPEby superfar21,706 views
- 2:41
MEP Exposes The EU Lisbon Treaty!!!by WeAreChangeIreland69,654 views
- 4:29
Abortion rights for Northern Ireland! London protestby jesseoldershaw782 views
- 7:24
005: You're Not Watching Friday.. Friday's Watching You!by FreshEire476 views
- 2:19
Lisbon Treaty 101: Why Ireland should VOTE NO on June 12thby lisbontreaty20086,796 views
- 5:22
Thank you Ireland for having saved our nation states today!by MayaGudrun7,730 views
- 0:29
European Police and Cosa Nostraby StopEU256 views
- 3:05
Lisbon Treaty and Keith Barryby vStreamStudio15,503 views
- 9:12
The Irish Government's deal on the LIsbon Treatyby KarenColemanIE376 views
- 2:46
Anti-abortion rally in Dublin 7.7.7by SafeMill1,465 views
- 2:57
Abortion Rights - extending rights to Northern Ireland womenby adycousins1,031 views
- 4:43
Ireland votes NO to Lisbon Treatyby LisbonTreatyNo8,803 views
- 1:45
Men and Abortion in Irelandby ChoiceIreland883 views
- 6:30
EPP Leaders on Irish Referendum of Lisbon Treaty & Economyby epppress913 views
- 1:08
David Andrews on Irish Neutrality and the Lisbon Treatyby YesToLisbon293 views
- 9:36
Lisbon Treaty: Labour Issues & Charter of Fundamental Rightsby eushorts225 views
- 8:05
The EU and the Irish referendumby MDreadedTV232 views
- 1:39
When NO is the better optionby LisbonVote39,148 views
The arguments put forward here are disingenuous. He seems to be arguing that somehow the ECJ could require Ireland to introduce abortion and same sex marriage as a result of the Charter of Fudamental Rights. The EU has no competences in relation to social legislation so the matter could never come before the Court. The Lisbon Treaty requires the EU to apply the CFR and the ECHR in its area of competances. It is fundamentally incorrect to suggest that Lisbon extends competances in this way.
padraigomairtin 2 years ago
Is a charter an act, or is it a charter?
christianpatriot125 2 years ago
Again. Key part of the phrase
OR ACTS MODIFYING OR SUPPLEMENTING THOSE TREATIES.
If the Charter is connected to the treaty of Lisbon it is supplementing it, therefore it falls under protocol 35's ruling.
it is not a grey area.
connla 2 years ago
The Charter is not in the treaty, but is made legally binding by the treaty. Therefore you are into a grey area. The ECJ will decide, and generally the ECJ prefers universality to national exceptions. It is not as clear as you think.
christianpatriot125 2 years ago
Protocol 35 of the Lisbon Treaty says exactly Nothing in the Treaties, or in the Treaty establishing the European Atomic Energy Community, or in
the Treaties or Acts modifying or supplementing those Treaties, shall affect the application in Ireland of
Article 40.3.3 of the Constitution of Ireland.
THe courts MUST follow the protocols thus abortion has nothing to do with the lisbon treaty.
connla 2 years ago
think if we were alright with abrtion it woulda been accepted but it aint and fair play.
stevienickslover 2 years ago
I'll be voting a big fat juicy NO again. The EU is fast becoming a dictatorship with no respect for Democracy.
ANTONELIUSMCGREGOR 2 years ago