Vocal Battle: Carrie Underwood vs. Taylor Swift (Part 1)

***I own NOTHING in this video!

a side-by-side vocal comparison between Carrie Underwood and 2009's reigning Female Vocalist of the Year: Taylor Swift.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• carrie
• underwood
• taylor
• swift
• faith
• hill
• female
• vocalist
• of
• the
• year
• entertainer
• cma
• martina
• mcbride
• gretchen
• wilson
• reba
• wynona
• judd
• kellie
• pickler
• miley
• cyrus
• phil
• stacey
• miranda
• lambert
• kanye
• west
• vma
• beyonce
• chris
• brown
• rihanna
• diane
• sawyer
• interview
• grammy
• changed
• man
• AMA
• album
• lady
• gaga
• adam
• michael
• janet
• jackson

[peaceloveerin100]

Its pretty obvious Carrie wins hands down!! Taylor sounds like a dying cat when she sings live!

[hedunlap]

A better video would be a Taylor Swift vs William Hung. At least theres some comparison between those two.

[xxxTeamUnderwoodxxx]

We already know Carrie wins, BY FAR. Comparing Taylor to Carrie is like comparing a cat to a lion. The cat being Taylor, the lion being Carrie, in case you're ignorant.

[imbeagleek66]

To Taylor,

Screaming while running over explosives doesn't qualify as singing.

Love, people who know good music.

[CPicked]

Honestly is this really a battle!

Taylor writes really nice songs, but can she please ask someone else to sing them. But people keep buying her albums like it's all good. So I blame the public!

[matthew777stone]

Carrie won before it even started, and no offense to taylor im sure shes nice but she cant sing.

[FreshTilDeath28]

comparison? you're joking right. there's no one in country music that can rightfully be compared to Carrie Underwood. period.

[nercole94hellyeah]

there is no comparison at all, carrie underwood dominates

[zoyuxi]

@Xzamilloh I happen to like both singers, but I agree they are at way diff. levels. Carrie is way better vocally. And lyrically, I actually prefer Carrie too. I like Taylor Swift in a more 'guilty pleasure' sense. Her songs are more 'fun' / 'get up and dance to' type. Taylor might work well in being behind the scenes, as an instrumentalist/songwriter for someone who can sing better. And it'd be nice if she got some formal vocal training. That could make her much better live.

[blin510]

I just noticed that all the comments that say Taylor wins got deleted by whoever's video this is.

I'm not surprised....

If they didn't delete them, comments about Taylor winning will be overflowing.

[8484carito]

Ay noo, ni punto de comparación. A Taylor comparenla con Demi o con Miley, pobrecita ella es muy dulce y vende por montones, pero comparararla con Carrie es hacerla quedar en ridículo, como ocurrió en este video.

[hershey976]

I love Taylor and Carrie so much, but their vocal is as different as day and night, There is no comparison at all.