Kubrick vs Scorsese

Kubrick and Scorsese. Two great directors, superb movies, with extremely talented actors at their disposal. But which one is the better director...
It's a simple survey, so comment as to you think is better. -Thanks

Category:

Film & Animation

Tags:

• Kubrick
• Martin
• Scorsese
• Contest
• Survey
• Director
• Movies
• Clockwork
• Orange
• Casino
• The
• Departed
• Eyes
• Wide
• Shut
• Barry
• Lyndon

[PescopagonaPictures]

@tagadi22 sorry man, i made the music myself on garageband.

[PescopagonaPictures]

Its a very difficult question. By necessity, Scorsese descends/derives from Kubrick, and yet appears, at times, to surpass him. Scorsese is best when he deals with domestic stories, individuals; he is a very colloquial, settled director. Meanwhile, Kubrick is all over the board; never sticking to one genre, one never senses he has a Kubrickian touch, a STYLE, which is a rather odd observation, as all his films are rather stylized (to the point of being rigid). I enjoy the discussion thus far

[3Axy10Est13]

@GretaGargoyle semi-illiterate...because i wrote tho? you dont have any intellectual thing to say so you have to point out a mispelled word, i know how to spell you ignorant tool. The Coen Brothers are overated as hell. Burn After Reading was painfull to watch, they try way to hard to be unique and end up making shit films because of it.

[GretaGargoyle]

@3Axy10Est13 seriously, WO GIVES A FLYING FUCK what your sad, semi-literate ass thinks about anything?

[TheWesternMafia1237]

Coen brothers are the only good directors that are out right now

[ohweloveeverton]

i cant watch another one of these

Kubrick vs. Scorsese is like the Yankees vs. professional bowling

[3Axy10Est13]

I hate the coen Brothers Kubrick wins Scorses is amazing tho

[TheWesternMafia1237]

So many directors look up to these guys without them movies would suck Coen Brothers Tarantino these guys both inspire them Coen Bros are big fans of Kubrick.

[BurnedSmileyFace]

What do we decide? You either enjoy their work or you don't. Its not a competition. I learned alot of both of them. I have 12 fathers and they are two of them.

[saqibk1]

Kubrick off course and then Polanski.

[Gaston088able]

Both are GREAT and they are 2 of the best filmakers in HISTORY!...Im a little more fan of MARTY SCORSESE,but KUBRICK is GOD! I dont like the list of films... SCORSESE PICTURES: 1-RAGING BULL. 2-TAXI DRIVER. 3-GOODFELLAS. 4-THE AGE OF INNOCENE.(masterpiece of period,beautiful film) 5-THE AVIATOR. 6-AFTER HOURS. 7-THE LAST THEMPTATION OF CRHIST. 8-THE DEPARTED. 9-GANGS OF NEW YORK. 10-CASINO. 11-SHUTTER ISLAND. 12-MEAN STREETS. IN THE KUBRICK LIST ARE MISS 2: FULL METAL JACKET DR. STRANGELOVE.

[snapsoidpablo1]

Imagine if Kubrick directed "Taxi Driver" - that seems like an interesting way to compare the two directors. Or Scorsese directing "Full Metal Jacket"