Uploader Comments (isayovids)
Top Comments
-
It's a great cover, no doubt. I just don't think it captures the true meaning of the song the way that Elliott's original, more melancholy version does. Still very good though.
-
Elliott Smith actually did his own rock version of this song, so this is a notch down from that. A worthy attempt, of course. Just not as good as the originals.
All Comments (48)
-
@niedec lame - o
-
I just heard of these guys just now and downloaded their discography without knowing this song was on there. I'm a fucking huge Elliott Smith fan, i have a half sleeve on my arm dedicated to him, and this is fucking awesome. Best Christmas present from a band i have never heard of ever.
-
I listened to this version first in some bmx comercial, but I like Elliott's version the same. .
-
I actually heard this version before Elliot Smith's and this was one of my least favorite on the album. Once I heard Elliot's original, I really liked his version, and once I heard this one again, I started to really like it. Don't know why, but it totally rocks now, all credit to Elliot.
-
Both versions (Smith + Bad Astronaut) are so sad. But, tribute to Elliott Smith, this version is even better. Sorry. I like Joey. he´s a good guy. Hope Lagwagon would be on tour in germany.
-
@xmfdibujito Kurt Cobain does not belong in the same breath as Elliott Smith and Jeff Buckley.
-
not really what i expected



Wow...if I heard this version first, I probably wouldn't want to hear the original.
siapeaches 2 years ago
me too
isayovids 2 years ago