Leona Lewis vs Alexandra Burke: Without You

Both female winners of the X-Factor singing the Mariah Carey Classic. The question is: Who sang it best?

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• alex vs leona
• without you
• x factor
• mariah carey
• leona
• alex

[Musicluv3R4life1997]

Leona's Better, Obviously......Luv U Leona!

[12345Elenia]

leona lewis beats alexandra burke hands down :) xxx

[nawnawjunior]

I like alexandra voice because she has not only big voice but also beautiful tone

[cantbeliev]

@Musicluv3R4life1997

i don't understand why Alex always makes the note lower@"@

that just make the song's original feeling being lost~

TOO BAD~

[abstellkamer]

leonaaaaa-3

[kcwacey]

both fantastic.... thats why they both have gone far ... simple as

[1994rollercoaster1]

there both just as good in different ways...

[ordinaaryy]

Alexandra!!!!

[shardsofsteel]

First the sound is bad quality. But it's really a bad idea to compare artists. It's like comparing different cultures food. You can't compare Japanese food with West African food. It's your taste. I personally think Leona has a fantastic voice, but I don't care for most of her music. Alexandra's voice is different. It is pitched lower, throatier (imo) and heavier. So comparing does no good here. Your talking preference not quality.

[MarkSmithHD]

Alexandra by far.

[OOO1239]

Leona RAPED Alex

[Stefano94x]

Alexandra.