Ibn Ishaq's work, if there was any, is non existent. Story is made that Ishaq's scribes proceeded with the work of Ibn Ishaq. The scribes work is also not available. Ibn Hisham cleverly used the name Ibn Ishaq for establish legitimacy of his fictional book 'Seerat Rasoolah' which is mother of seerat books.. Now Hisham is absolved of the lies contained in his book. The real name of I.S is AbdulMalik. He is a 9th century Egyptian, who had no sources to know about the life of Mohammad.
Ibn Ishaq's work, if there was any, is non existent. Story is made that Ishaq's scribes proceeded with the work of Ibn Ishaq. The scribes work is also not available. Ibn Hisham cleverly used the name Ibn Ishaq for establish legitimacy of his fictional book 'Seerat Rasoolah' which is mother of seerat books.. Now Hisham is absolved of the lies contained in his book. The real name of I.S is AbdulMalik. He is a 9th century Egyptian, who had no sources to know about the life of Mohammad.
reasonlight 1 year ago