magnetogravitic motor.wmv
Uploader Comments (teslacult)
Video Responses
All Comments (45)
-
YOU MUST try with more than 1 ring and also changing the numbers to 12 in the first ring, 24 in the second one and so on, that could work.
-
@ZeroFossilFuel refer to your statement above "BUT, there is also a linear force equal and opposite that cancels out the unidirectional motion along the planetary gear " I think u should try all the Bar magnet with either north pole is more stronger field strength then south or vice versa.. hope this will kick start in 1 direction with less number of Magnet Layout
-
Very interesting concept. Very similar design to EDL's work, which is theorized to be a perfect balance of flowing magnetic current. If you haven't yet, look into Edward Leedskalnin's work and modify your mock-up accordingly (if needed) before taking the time to make the prototype. Everything you have here "appears" inline (almost exactly with what EDL what doing), but always good to use his work as a source, it may help.
In 2008. I had identical idea for construction you show here. It is amazing for me to see it on YouTube. I am shocked now! And I spend few days in calculating forces. I made mathematical model and analyze system stability . I am graduated mechanical engineer and I have grate knowledge in control systems.There are few points of stability and that is reason why this system is not perpetuum mobile. But very close :) Nikola Tesla was Serbian as I am. We are all proud of him. Greetings from Serbia!
vrangavran 1 year ago
@vrangavran Thanks for your comments.
teslacult 10 months ago
Okay, I've been playing with a few magnets by hand and studying the forces. There is a rotational force on the pinion magnet causing it to rotate in one direction. BUT, there is also a linear force equal and opposite that cancels out the unidirectional motion along the planetary gear surface. Same is true of the pinions in relation to the inner rotor spur gear.
Bottom line, it won't work.
Still moving forward with my VFPMM
ZeroFossilFuel 1 year ago 2
@ZeroFossilFuel I don't know. I have done this as well and I didn't notice any opposition to the movement. It seemed to me that the rotating magnet seemed to just slide right out of the surrounding fields. Also, you have to account for the planetary gear moving within the field of new magnets as it rotates. You could be correct, but I think the only way to know for sure would be to build it. Also, accelerating the gear system could have an effect on how the forces interact as well.
teslacult 1 year ago
I definitely give this concept a thumbs up. Saving the video for the archives. Have any prototypes been made yet?
@FUNNUMS Throttle would be easy. Just shift the outer planetary gear relative to the outer magnets.
ZeroFossilFuel 1 year ago
@ZeroFossilFuel Thanks. Good idea with the throttle. No prototype has ever been built, to my knowledge, but the video is most popular in Russia and Ukrane, so who knows.
teslacult 1 year ago