Fringe 3x09 "Marionette - Peter/Olivia End Scene "She wasn't me."

This is the MOST HEARTBREAKING SCENE between Peter and Olivia ever. Not only of the episode, but of the entire show.

Anna Torv, you are EXTRAORDINARY. Josh Jackson, you're not bad yourself, but I'm sorry to say, Anna stole the episode! AMAZINGLY HEARTBREAKING FROM BEGINNING TO END!

Olivia: You know what Barrett said? He said that he looked into her eyes, and he knew that it wasn't her. ... I understand the facts. I know that she had reams of information about me, and about my life, and about the people that were close to me. And I understand that if she slipped up, she would have a completely reasonable explanation for it, and I guess to expect you to have seen past that is perhaps asking a little bit too much. But when I was over there, I thought about you, and you were just a figment of my imagination, but I held on to you, and it wasn't reasonable, and it wasn't logical, but I did it, so, why didn't you? She wasn't me. How could you not see that? Now, she's everywhere; she's in my house, my job, my bed, and I don't wanna wear my clothes anymore and I don't wanna live in my apartment, and I don't wanna be with you. She's taken everything.

Peter (when Olivia's gone): I'm sorry.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Fringe
• 3x09
• marionette
• Polivia
• Olivia
• Peter
• ending
• sad
• Anna
• Torv
• Joshua
• Jackson

[YanaMontana1]

Anna Torv definitely needs Emmy for this.

[GenoBreaker90113]

Until Fringe, I never exactly got my emotions evoked by a television show and for years I've been watching it with a passion...but this scene was so sad a heart-wrenching, and it honestly almost brought a tear to my eye. I really, really hope that Olivia forgives Peter someday.

[fadsforwhatever]

I really liked the way Fringe dealt with this. It's a complicated, messy, painful situation for both of them and both actors do a superb job of conveying that. You can feel Peter's pain and guilt and shame (and how he's holding back because he knows Olivia needs to grieve) and Olivia's utter raw feeling of betrayal in their performances. Peter's belief that Altlivia was his Olivia and Olivia's complete breakdown are both so believable and realistic. What a fantastic (painful!) show.

[RUMHAM]

@cru182 yep 

[cru182]

thumbs up if tv.com review, brought you here

[ascascable]

u kno that was like the most realistic reaction of someone who had been replaced. awesome

[SocietysLonely]

@priscilla280 I never thought of that, but I think you're right

well done. Oh it makes even harder now

[SocietysLonely]

@cherrylipstick87 forget fringe, Best scenes in TV ever!

[SocietysLonely]

@MayBrainLee1 Just Shut Up!

For your own sake

[jreckdahl]

Should have been at least nominated for an Emmy with this scene alone. Stupid voters.

[shampoomomo]

I used to hate Peter because of this. He didn't see through that AltLivia. And now ss 4 frustrates me that the producers are breaking them up again after Olivia forgave Peter and they got together. Come on!!!!!!!

[Damon242]

This is yet another reason why season 4 is bugging me. We went through all of this with Olivia, her suffering, and then went through everything in the second half of season 3 involving them coming back together...ONLY to now be watching Peter unable to get to her.

We've already been through this before...

[Splinki]

"She wasn't me...How could you not see that ?" This sentence made me cry. I'm glad she finally let it out. I also would have felt this way you know, "I understand the facts", it should make sense but my heart just can't accept that.

[movieartman]

taken out of contex i can see that MABYE some might see this as overacting (idots) but when u consider the 2 previous scenes (also extremly well done by miss torv) in this episode witch led to this scene where olive final just lets it out to peter......... it is FLAWLESS anna torv is officaly my fav actress

[movieartman]

this scene anna takes this to a whole new level man. OMG i love this show

[HeyHiHelloHard]

Anna Torv did a GREAT job here.So did the writers.They showed us that,despite everything,Olivia is a human being.And even though she understands why Peter didn't notice it was Alt!Livia,she still wanted him to.Selfish?Maybe,but everyone is a bit selfish,and Olivia is no exception.She was replaced by a girl who was nothing like her,and nobody,not even Peter, could tell the difference.Like nobody knew or loved her enough to realize she wasn't there.That's gotta be frustrating,at least.

[Desmond8043]

In this scene, I think Peter finally understands why Walter stole him, and why it drove him insane. From this episode on, Peter does more and more with Walter, slowly rebuilding their relationship back up. It was an incredible episode, one of Fringe's best. One of Anna Torv's greatest performances. Emmy worthy!

[AesaFilms]

Heavy scene.

[xoxoMSpiGGY]

i love this scene! so beautifully written and acted by anna...all her built up emotion came out and it felt perfect....it wasnt too much nor did it seem like she was overreacting.....after all shes been through i feel like she deserved to vent....prob the first time to see her truly emotional.....i watched all three seasons in a week and this scene is truly one of my favs....cant wait for next season!

[stela1011]

Amazing scene just amazing....... For me this is the best scene in season 3.

[angelagr84]

God I love this scene!

[lostie17]

I hope Anna Torv gets at least an Emmy nomination for this!

[soccaluva94]

"She wasn't me. How could you not see that?"

This line just gets me. It's so beautifully written and Anna says it perfectly.

[lordseshomaru86]

watch this vid then immediately watch their last scene from 3x21 it's amazing to see how they endured and came back stronger than ever!! Olivia x Peter always!!

[carlacds]

yeah, I think so too. For some reason it seems to me that he even has more chemistry with her (even though I know the actor is the same)