Tenri High School Band 1990 Symphony 5 Finale
Top Comments
All Comments (32)
-
Yeah my high school band is playing this and hearing this makes me want to cry because they are sooooo amazing and we well......
-
@kabalahman You're preaching to the choir! I've been a professional musician for 40 years - master's from Juilliard. This is a High School Band, not NY Philharmonic. They are at their best in the fast sections - driving and exciting. In slower passages (horn solo, woodwind solos) he's just time-beating. There's no shape in the phrasing, no music. However, these are youngsters and overall they do a good job playing this challenging piece. Looks like you're into new age.mostly?
-
@maestrojimbo as has been overstated already, technicality and precision are fantastic for this group at this level; HOWEVER, the musicality is lacking... musicality invests the composer's intention and vision for the piece which is MORE than merely playing the notes set down on a piece of paper - and again, what would another judge know from technicality/precision versus musicality?
-
Blame the conductor for the flabby tempi in places - most of it is good, but lacking in sense of direction. Check out the Cass Tech H S Band version I recently posted.
-
@maestrojimbo details are important, but what's really important is the big picture. their playing was too rigid and structured in my opinion, and i couldn't derive the true intent of the piece from this performance alone. but that's just me, i'm a douchebag judge so don't mind me.
-
the one who dislike this video doesnt habe any ears!!!!!
-
As a trumpet player of nearly a decade, I am EXTREMELY impressed with the tonality and blending of the trumpet section! It's really quite nice.
I do agree with another comment here that they are very precise, but maybe lacking a bit of the musicality?
-
they all sound really good and unified, but the style and musicality is wrong in a lot of places. it's not always about getting every note and rhythm exactly precise, it's about making music out of the tune.
-
この大会はレベル高過ぎだった!!常総のサロメも最高だった!
As a wood wind player...I am amazed at this performance. I can hear every part of the articulations. Even at the speed they are playing , in the beginning, its very clean and they are maintaining the tone quality and intonation very well
turnne 2 years ago 10
damn. Why are the Japanese so good at everything? They even make the best food...
hcvideoproductions 1 year ago 8