Top Comments
All Comments (78)
-
@luvart2607 No, they are both good in their own individual way and it's great to be able to hear both. Really great song.
-
Art is the best!
-
i used to be a dee-jay at a club in buffalo in the 70s.when it was time to slow it down i always played this song.it was always a popular choice.thanks for the memories.
-
2. I think Garfunkel was a di*k for even releasing it to begin with. He already had an established career, and Tim was just beginning to crest. I didn't discuss this point with TIm, but I'd like to know the story surrounding the reason Garfunkel rushed his out. I think it hurt Tim's chances, as, no matter what anybody thinks of either version, it's a great song that should be heard more, and should have gone further up the charts...at least IMO.
-
It might be that I'm a little jaundiced because I've been lucky enough to talk to Tim (on FB) about it, but I don't think so. I think the arrangement is better also. and...
-
I just listened to both this version and Art Garfunkel's version back-to-back...and I've got to say two things:
1. The song is a GREAT song, and so I don't think you could have a bad version of it. BUT...Garfunkel's version is so slow with that winey nasally style that Garfunkel can sometimes fall into...(even though he has a great voice in the upper register) that Tim's comes through with much more heart and soul for me,
-
Garfunkel's version was marshmellow, Tim's was the real thing. God bless him.
-
Think I heard Art's version first way back when,,,,,,,,,,,,but much perfer Tim's,,,,,guess as it sould be. From the heart of its master. Always beautiful and heartfelt,,,,,,days gone by.
-
Had this song on my mind all day -- I must've been thinking of someone who lived on Second Avenue in NY. Still get a lump in my throat when I hear it; sentimentality wins again. Such a simple song, and yet it cuts right to the heart.
-
where to download his albums? I can't find them anywhere...
As soon as this started playing, a shiver went down my spine - just like it used to way back in 1974 when I first heard it. What a sad, beautiful song !
bipolarbert 1 year ago 8
I was going to school in South Jersey in the early 70's when this song came out. I didn't realize Tim Moore was from Philly. Makes sense now. My girlfriend and I fell in love to the song. We've been married now for 34 years. Great memories....
TragicIndeed 1 year ago 4