Alert icon
We're changing our privacy policy. This stuff matters.  Learn more  Dismiss

Springfield XD9: Good Glock Alternative

Loading...

Sign in or sign up now!
326,688
Loading...
Alert icon
Sign in or sign up now!
Alert icon

Uploaded by on Nov 12, 2008

The XD is a good gun with excellent reliability and accuracy. In this series I compare it against my current standard in 9mm pistols, the Glock 17. In most respects, the XD designs takes its design cues directly from the Glock. Other downsides include a shiny non-tactical magazine, higher bore axis, an unneeded grip safety, and a heavier carry weight. Upsides include a better grip angle (ala 1911), ambidextrous mag release, a loaded chamber indicator, and more included accessories. My preferences lean towards the Glock but the XD9 is an outstanding alternative. There are many versions of the XD and any one would arm you well. ////////////////Nutnfancy Likeability Scale: 6 out of 10////////////Thanks to Impactguns.com for hosting this and many other TNP reviews!/////////////// If you own a gun of ANY kind and are not a member of the NRA you need to change your ways. Political battles rage that serve to disarm you, leaving you the potential victim of criminals who have NEVER obeyed gun laws. Join the NRA today for five years at a time and donate generously to the NRA/ILA. This is a patriotic, freedom organization that fights tirelessly to maintain our freedoms and it advocates no political party.////////////////////////////

Comparison to Glock 17, Nutnfancys 9mm standard. If a gun design exceeds the G17 standards in all categories over a long period, it will become the new standard of reference:
WEIGHT: Advantage Glock by 3 ounces
FIREPOWER: Tie with factory mags but advantage Glock with FACTORY 33 rd mag and +2 baseplates
DURABILITY: Advantage G17 durable for over 250,000 rounds; XD still proving this reputation
ACCURACY: Slight advantage G17 but your mileage may vary
SIGHTING RADIUS: Advantage G17
ERGONOMICS: Advantage G17 (unneeded grip safety but XD 1911 grip angle preferable)
SIMPLICITY: Advantage G17 (no grip safety)
ACCESSORIES: Mostly a tie
PRICE: Tie
TRACK RECORD: Advantage G17 so far, proven world wide for decades/////////////Also note: Some brand myopic viewers are infuriated with me when I do not review THEIR preferred gun (knife or other gear) in glowing terms. I will never compromise my integrity and will always deal the cards according to my preferences, experiences, and objective observations and I do so with no apologies. I dont do so to offend people but to maintain integrity in the reviews.

  • likes, 157 dislikes

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,396)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i got xd 40 and well i love it  shot it and a glock and i just like it more

  • Glock. My trigger finger is my safety.

  • im keeping it real, xd is better than the glock

  • Gun HS-9 as the most successful product of the Croatian military industry products HS Produkt of Karlovac. HS is a semi-automatic pistol gun that is sold under the name HS-9, HS-40, HS-45, (the number represents the caliber designation) on the Croatian market and markets outside the U.S., while sales in the U.S. market as the Springfield Armory "eXtreme Duty or XD-X (X is also a tag-caliber).

  • I personally like the XD better than the Glock because of the grip angle and grip safety.

  • xd gives more safety features than the glock.

  • besides all the features between the xd and the xdm is there a difference while shooting the xd and the xdm? debating on wich one to get, any advice will help thanks.

  • Does my jedi power sense bias with the aggression of a mac vs pc or chevy vs ford argument?

  • Made in Croatia

  • Imitation Glock.

View all Comments »
Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more