Nathaniel Marshall, Nancy Wilson & Kristen McNamara perform in Hollywood Week Group Day

They perform.

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Nathaniel
• Marshall
• Nancy
• Wilson
• Kristen
• McNamara
• American
• Idol
• Season
• Eight
• AI8
• Hollywood
• Week
• Group
• Day

[yusuckass8]

Kristen McNamara is the winner for this group :)

[mistermanish]

It doesnt take a genius to work out Kristen has talent. I think she was the best female of season 8 - they really stole it from her. :(

[ch0wac1]

kristen mcnamara is goooooooooood

[SteelAVic18]

Nancy borrowed Allison Irraheta's red ROCK Wig. lol

[pf243]

I felt bad for nancy, because she really tried, she stayed up all night willing to work and running after the other girl an her childish behaviour, i think the tension took a toll on her. I would be pissed of too if that happend. U didnt rehearse because Kristen kept whining and then wen things get bad she wants to hug nancy on stage, pleez

Oh well thats life, an it is a competition..

[aliceayrescloser]

Nancy was terrible. Nathaniel wasn't great. Kristen was just ok.

[bogiakhungbo]

Yeah, he was fun to watch, but he wasn't in this to win, he's not serious, while a lot of ppl out there r dying to have a chance to get in :-S

[americanidolkid]

nancy was doing fantastic until 0:19 she completly lost tune and tempo at that moment. kristin was good. nate is so... just "meh" quality. nothing great....

[o0ber]

Jamar's wife died too? Is that like, how they met (through some support group) because that's an awful coincidence.

[PenaltyKillah]

Jamar will be the Brandon (from SYTYCD) of American Idol next season. Trust me.

Honestly, I really hope he won't be exploiting his late wife (R.I.P.) like Danny Gokey did. Apologies for being a tad insensitive, but it has to be said.

[PenaltyKillah]

Sly of Nathaniel to sing a key lower. He seems to be channeling Adam Lambert, who performed earlier.

Nancy started well, though she sounded too much like Duffy, the original artist. Her fate was actually sealed when she flubbed at 0:25, then the other two stared to sing over her.

Kristen was totally unfazed by Nancy's revenged sabotaging and hit the high notes to save her own skin.

Ultimately, the judges made the right choice... Nancy would have caused unspeakable drama in the Finals anyway.

[PenaltyKillah]

Well, a few well-sung contestants were robbed in each stage just so that the judges (ahem, the producers) could pass Tatiana, Nick/Norman, I daresay, Jorge all the way to the Top 36 and beyond.

But c'mon, what'd you expect? If every contestant in the Hollywood round or the semi-finals are talented but without charisma, the ratings would just go way down. Thank your stars this season did not have Sanjayas and Picklers, and Jorge was out in the final's first week.