MACEDONIA - What THE HISTORY CHANNEL Says 5 of 5
Top Comments
All Comments (1,686)
-
@Oroposgr sorry leave instead of "live"
-
@Oroposgr I am sorry you are wrong. Aristotle was born in a very small town/village in Macedonia (Satgeira at Chalcidice) and he went to Athens to study at Plato's academy and he was exiled from there once because of being from Macedonia and went to teach Alexander and then he returned at Athens and established his own school there called the Lyceum. He had to live again when Alexander was killed. He went to live at the house he inherited from his mother at Chalcis.
-
@197ryder in other words, all the evidence to date is that you people of FYROM, wrongly called 'macedonians', are I2a2 Serbs, your haplogroups say so. And the latest genetic evidence not only agrees with this, but adds that you are the same people as Serbs AND BULGARIANS. Explains why you speak a dialect of Bulgarian. Although there is no genetic profile on the ancient Macedonians, the archaeological evidence confirms that the ancient Macedonians were Greeks.
-
However, the archaeological evidence CONFIRMS that
the ancient Macedonians of Alexander the Great were
an ethnic Greek tribe, of Greek stock, of Greek origins
speaking the Greek language, worshipping
Greek gods, with Greek place names, Greek names
of the months, and Greek personal names.
The ancient Macedonians had integrated with
the rest of the tribes of Greece in a policy enforced by
Philip and continued under Alexander.
-
"Direct descent from the ancient Macedonians???"
You can bullshit the bullshitters, but you can't bullshit me.
No DNA data is available on the ancient Macedonians,
because none has ever been revcovered from the ancient
Macedonian graves,of which about 900 have been investigated
in Vergina (Aegae).That means there is no DNA signature
on the ancient Macedonians. In otherwords to date,
nobody has any idea what the genetic profile of the
ancient Macedonians is.
-
@97ryder Don't talk bollocks with me, the haplogroups of the so-called 'macedonians' of FYROM are I2a2 , meaning you are the same people as Serbs. But strangely enough you speak Bulgarian. Now oddly enough, the latest genetic study on you 'macedonians' of FYROM shows that you are the same people as Serbs AND Bulgarians. That just confirms what your have been saying all the time, and also what anthropologists have been saying all the time, that you are BULGARO-SERBS.
-
I don't know what you mean "the Macedonians were
Barbarians and spoke Greek with an accent."
Athenians considered most other Greeks as Barbarians
including the Spartans. And all the individual
Greek tribes spoke with their own individual dialects.
Spartans spoke in the Laconian dialect, Boeotians
in the Boeotian dialect and the Macedonians, Akarnanians
and Aetolians spoke in an Aeolic/Doric Greek dialect.
So what????
-
@HaggisMacfee let dont agree with that and stop fighting because we are not going anywhere
-
@HaggisMacfee Much greater detail on the direct descent of today's Macedonians from the ancient Macedonians is found in "THE DESCENDANTS OF ALEXANDER THE GREAT OF MACEDON - The arguments and evidence that today's Macedonians are descendants of the ancient Macedonians"
-
@HaggisMacfee And most convincing of all the fact that the genetic research had proven that the Macedonians are not Slavs but have a direct descent from the ancient Macedonians
@MrKristijan97 Seriously when you know nothing...you better not speak.The macedonian language is the greek language...You language is slavic.Ancient macedonians didnt speak the slavic language but the greek one and that is confirmed by the thousand scripts we have found all over macedonia...Your nation came in the 6th century AD...Thats almost 800 years after alexander the great.You have been brainwashed...Your english need some work
asfaehey 1 week ago 9
@asfaehey some work.His english needs every work possible
lodhol 1 week ago 4