Deceptive Methodologies & False Claims... (1 of 2)

Iceyyy in the comments section of a video I did posted many links as "evidence" for the claim that Muhammad (pbuh) ordered women to suckle adults. A brief examination of the links, comments and claim: Some observations and comments...

Please see Part 2 for the full picture:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2r6-dG6WJKw

Excellent refutation Video by IqraProductions (Must See):

Explaining the Hadith Series 5 - (Suckling & Nose Blowing)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-h00a8_OVg

Resources:

1) Translation of Sahih Muslim, Book 8

http://www.usc.edu/dept/MSA/fundamentals/hadithsunnah/muslim/008.smt.html

Check Hadith Numbers: 3371-3388 which are nothing to do with suckilng.

Check Hadith Numbers: 3424-3428 which all deal with ONE incident.

Check Hadith Number: 3429 which Iceyyy didnt want you to see, as it clarifies that this one incident is an exception.

2) A Scholar responds to the Question: Is it permissible to breast-feed a child over 2 years old?

http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=721&ln=eng

3) A Scholar responds to the question: I understand that a child becomes "related" to a woman when he nurses from her. Does he also become related if he receives her breastmillk in a bottle ?

http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=1488&ln=eng

Peace, fot

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• islam
• false
• mohammad
• quran
• devils
• book
• jesus
• bible
• satan
• christ
• jews
• moses
• noah
• christians
• faith
• religion

[joints1979]

thanks for your reply....the point i am trying to make is ,i find it ironic when the muslims try to clame how the bible is corrupted by mentioning the similar type of sources ,but the same doesnt apply to them....

[thefotfoundation]

I have never used newspaper articles or TV reports to make judgments about Christianity.

A cursory look at the theology and method salvation proposed in Christianity in enough to show that Christianity does not make sense (at least to me).

That God blamed all of Mankind for a couples sin and was unable to forgive sin so became His Own Son and killed Himself to pay Himself the price of sin (which He had set).

Dont even ask me to talk about the Trinity.

Sources of critique are not the same.

[thefotfoundation]

In terms of the corruption of the Bible, the fact that Christendom has not agreed on what the Bible constitutes (the Catholic and Protestant Bibles differing by SEVEN Whole books) is enough of a sign of corruption.

Furthermore look at the Codex Sianaticus (390AD) containing the Epistle of barnabas and the Gospel of the shepherd of Hermes, which are not in any of todays Bibles.

So again the sources of critique are not the same.

[joints1979]

i am from an arab christian ,and what she wrote is known by the arab world ,but taken as taboo or talking oor menisioning is aganist islamto speak about them.thats why donot you only see dibates with western christians but never with eastern orthodox christians.

[thefotfoundation]

Thanks for your comment. What she wrote of course was based upon a Newspaper article about Al-Azhar.

This is not taboo because the people that were talking/discussing about breast-feeding were some Muslim Scholars at Al-Azhar, hence the erroneous fatwa (legal opinion) that was later retracted.

Your point about the debates doesnt make sense, please clarify.

[brotherjupiter]

The fotfoundation,

Since no one has had any luck getting a Muslim on youtube to denounce the disturbing pattern that shows, once a nation becomes a muslim majority, Islamic theocratic governments become the norm and democracy is seriously curtailed.

So how about addressing this glaring problem with Islam.

[thefotfoundation]

Your assuming that there are any Muslim theocracies currently and that I agree that theocracy is a glaring problem.

I see why you may have had that problem with the denouncements.

[binshamak]

Neutralangelofwisdom, A shaved man looks like a featherless chicken.

[dankwilliams]

Are you filming from a pharmacy?

[OyonTheAdept]

quran is fake. and corrupt.

do yourself a favor and research on it? and you'll know what i am talking about.

[MrGrandDragon]

Prophets are needed to guide the people form amongst them. They need guidance. God does not just forgive, you have to ASK and sincerely REPENT. This is not a concept known to Christians since they live in pompous delusion claiming to have already been atoned for in the merciless slaughter of Gods own Son (God) ...

You need to think more deeply

[LothairOfLorraine]

There are several. But, to make it easy on you, I'll let you define 'theocracy'. Then we'll get into why Islamic theocracy is indeed a 'glaring problem'.

It's funny to read that western converts to Islam like the idea of theocracy. Obviously, you have never had to live under one!

[LothairOfLorraine]

You identified the problem here. You made only a 'cursory' inspection of Christian theology.

So, God can just forgive sin, right? He doesn't need the Atonement of Christ? Then why does he need prophets or books? Why not just forgive us all? Fot, you really need to think out the implications of your thoughts before you just go about quoting atheists like Shabir Ally, whose methodology refutes his own belief system.

[binshamak]

not by Eisha but her sister .any way this is not the main view

[controlyourownmind]

how do u come to know that as a fact without a leap of faith?

[SexyManFromIran]

find the truth

jesus save you

islam is nothing more than a mutation of christianity

Christianity is the only true way