Change Player Size
Watch this video in a new window

Napoleon Bonaparte

history video  
 
Customize

More From: ranmafrontru

Loading...

QuickList(0)

Upgrade to Flash Player 10 for improved playback performance. Upgrade Now or get more info.
148 ratings
Sign in to rate
165,916 views
Want to add to Favorites? Sign In or Sign Up now!
Want to add to Playlists? Sign In or Sign Up now!
Want to flag a video? Sign In or Sign Up now!

Statistics & Data

Loading...

Video Responses (0)

This video has no Responses. Be the first to Post a Video Response.
Sign in to post a Comment

Text Comments (366)   Options

Loading...
athpot (5 days ago)
Comment removed by author
NapoleonCalland (1 week ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
As for living off the land, that deserves nuancing because he was the only one who tried to minimise the suffering of civilians (he compensated those whose houses were destroyed for example) and his preparations included as much provision of food as possible. Living off the land was a last resort when the commissariat broke down. Compare that with the Prussian or Russian forces who wantonly destroyed everything in their path !
sugarraygras (1 week ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
Fair play to you and your encyclopedic knowledge of Napoleons personal account of his career, with your additional background reading of the accounts of his apologists, however I feel you admire this guy to the point of worship. It is a common phenomenon. However I feel you need to look at the other side of the argument before drawing your conclusions.
NapoleonCalland (6 days ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
AJP Taylor, Cronin and Asprey are not Napoleonic "apologists".

And I was looking at the other side of the argument when I drew my conclusions. Hence the admiration for the one guy who tried to limit the damage caused by a revolution he found himself in the middle of and of wars he didn't start.
sugarraygras (6 days ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
As Napoleon said himself,"The truth is but a set of lies agreed upon", so I suppose that means we all have our own truths dependant on the information we recieve. I have read a lot about Napoleon and my French wife and her brothers, who attended top Parisian schools founded by the man himself, are all of the opinion he was a dictator. I only mention this so you do not assume that I present the english view!
NapoleonCalland (6 days ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
Most of the Parisian schools you mentioned teach the doctored version of History that the dwarfs in power like people to believe in order to justify their dictatorship. People like your wife and brothers in law tend to change their minds if they do their own reading based on period accounts.
sugarraygras (6 days ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
Wellington was a highly questinable person and politician but a good general. The monarchy is a smile on a dog!
NapoleonCalland (6 days ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
A smile on a dog ?
NapoleonCalland (1 week ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
My advice is to remember that the abject barbarisms you're talking about were the reaction to a treasonous attack on French troops organised by imams who wanted to take advantage of the fact that he'd kicked out the Mamelukes in order to take power. Despite his generals demanding that he burn the mosques in retribution for the wounded and civilians (French and Egyptian alike) who had been slaughtered in the hospitals, he refused and only executed those bearing arms.
NapoleonCalland (1 week ago) Show Hide
 0
Marked as spam
@royalsteven He was 5"6 in British imperial measurements and the wars he fought began 7 years before he came to power. The sad part is that he gets accused of warmongering today by people who don't know their History and just look at the map

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.