Uploaded by MenoftheInfinite on Jul 7, 2009
Observations on Genius by Otto Weininger.
A video produced by Kevin Solway.
Otto Weininger on the Internet:
http://www.theabsolute.net/ottow/
Quotations on Genius:
http://www.theabsolute.net/minefield/genqtpg.html
Background music from Coolangubra.
http://www.amazon.com/Coolangubra/e/B000APW9YA
------
Don't forget, for topical responses, "Men of the Finite":
http://www.youtube.com/MenoftheFinite
Category:
Tags:
License:
Standard YouTube License
-
84 likes, 35 dislikes
Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (MenoftheInfinite)
Video Responses
All Comments (128)
-
@mrconradhoppe Yes, but we are pieces that can think for ourselves and speculate about the universe. So we are not 'just' pieces.
atticana 9 months ago
-
@KevinSolway I will ponder upon your words and respond to them when I have pondered sufficiently.
atticana 9 months ago
-
@atticana If your God is not literally everything then it follows that your God is finite. This is a logical necessity, and there is no way around it.
KevinSolway 9 months ago
-
@KevinSolway I am most certainly making that assumption. God, the Creator of all, is separate and distinct from His creation. I reject both pantheism and panentheism.
atticana 9 months ago
-
@atticana You are assuming that God is not all things (ie, the Universe).
KevinSolway 9 months ago
-
@SecularNumanist The universe is not endless, that would imply infinity. Everything created is necessarily finite. Only the Creator, God, is infinite.
atticana 10 months ago
-
and how would you know about this other dimension? have you been there?
SecularNumanist 10 months ago
-
the universe is not hierarchichal, it is an endless plane with no up or down.
SecularNumanist 10 months ago
-
how do you know how many videos youve viewed? "total upload views" refers to the amount of views all of your videos have received in total
SecularNumanist 10 months ago
-
we all are genius, a socially accepted or recognized genius, that s another matter
phiphers 1 year ago
4:32
Life Philosophy of the Homeless Geniusby me3tv17,464 views
8:28
Wide Worldby MenoftheInfinite1,726 views
3:21
God does not existby MenoftheInfinite20,060 views
9:04
Pwnage, ownage, and onanismby MenoftheInfinite2,956 views
4:35
The Ultimate Truth?by MenoftheInfinite2,917 views
7:30
Youtube Atheist Evolutionary Treeby MenoftheInfinite5,197 views
2:43
Friedrich Nietzsche on Master and Slave Moralityby HourOfDecision7779,316 views
7:49
Philosophy is Not for the Faint Heartedby MenoftheInfinite1,714 views
5:34
Reincarnation / rebirthby MenoftheInfinite6,178 views
4:46
Time to Evolveby MenoftheInfinite1,590 views
5:10
Thus Spake Zarathustraby MenoftheInfinite3,729 views
3:18
WHITE GENOCIDEby Truthisahatecrime95,249 views
1:59
A User's Guide to Relativismby MenoftheInfinite1,449 views
4:43
Religion and Samsaraby MenoftheInfinite607 views
0:59
New channel: Men of the Finiteby MenoftheInfinite743 views
6:07
Misogynist Lit. 3: The Wise Manby KellyJones00483 views
3:48
A=A Techno Mixby MenoftheInfinite1,001 views
10:31
Where Science and Buddhism Meet PART 1by GeraldP1983494,410 views
5:11
Barbra Streisand - Somewhereby flashdance832,769,094 views
9:06
Coolangubraby BertholdIon969 views
- Loading more suggestions...
Weininger's comments on the genius seem to be mostly right, but I have to reject this notion that any human being can fully transcend the influence of his own age. Aristotle, for instance, was a multifaceted genius and his works, while many of his ideas are original, can be placed in a historical context where he either built upon the works of previous thinkers who were also somewhat external to the mainstream or he even took up some mainstream assumptions such as sexism without question.
Thucydides2004 2 years ago
I think Otto was talking about fundamentals rather than contingent details. Every person has to re-invent the philosophical wheel. And those fundamentals transcend history and culture. I've always found cultural references in both Otto and Nietzsche to be a bit dodgy, depending on the context.
MenoftheInfinite 2 years ago
Philosophers tend to define the term 'genius' in suspicious ways...
Mattprole 2 years ago
You mean in a way that makes *them* the genius?
MenoftheInfinite 2 years ago
Yeah, I think Schopenhauer did the same thing too.
Mattprole 2 years ago
Well, you could consider the concept of genius spoken of in this vid - and by Weininger - as "philosophical genius", which sets it apart in type from musical or mathematical genius etc...
MenoftheInfinite 2 years ago