@UrukEngineer I agree with your statements here too. Just that I think there is evidence to support belief in God. There's too many people that don't know what they believe, just taking on their family's traditions and assuming it as their own.
Yeah, I'd agree. Either way, it's a person's own worldview, and I'd prefer it if people openly listened to each others' POVs and didn't shove it down each others' throats.
I definitely have considered that I may be entirely wrong and that there is no God, nor gods. There's still the doubt in the back of my mind that says maybe I'm wrong, but every time I've entertained those thoughts, I've found too much evidence for a God to be convinced otherwise.
@andrewccal “just because the doctrine (or scientific theory) is not agreeable it may still be true” I whole heartedly agree. I hope that you can see that statement working both for and against any religious belief.
Would you be willing to consider that you might be wrong? There may be no god(s)?
@andrewccal Many people say they are Atheist (and put no caveat on it) because they just find their native religion unpleasant or illogical. Their Atheism is a reaction to religion. However when pressed they acknowledge that a human can’t know everything about everywhere, so the existence of a god(s) can’t be ruled out. Critically however, an Atheist’s position is that there is no evidence to support a belief in god(s).
@UrukEngineer I totally agree that Christians often apply these doctrines in horrible ways like picketing a gay person's funeral or justifying abuse of women's rights, but that doesn't make the fundamental doctrine false.
Also, if Christians need to recognize their worldview as an opinion, so should atheists. The core of an atheist's identity is that there is no God, something that can't be proven definitively either way. They are just mutually exclusive worldviews, not superior or inferior.
@UrukEngineer There are two issues here. 1) Historicity of the bible and ideas 2) Christian response to these ideas. There is evidence for Jesus'existence, resurrection, and the resulting movement that is connected to His claim to being God. That can be debated. However, just because the doctrine is not agreeable it may still be true. I don't like gravity, but I can't say it's wrong because I don't like it and it causes a lot of people hip fractures.
@andrewccal Christains however don't recognise their worldviews as "opinions", they form the core of their identity. Because they have "raised the stakes" in this way, ANY critism of their worldview is seen by them as a personal attack. I would rather they did not feel that way.
@andrewccal You are right, insulting one another gets us no where. I am, by nature, somewhat direct...but I hate rudeness.
The problem is that religious beliefs lack the evidence to place them on the same level as even tentative scientific theories. Therefore religious opinions should be open to robust scrutiny particularly as they support misogyny, homophobia and other unpleasant behaviour.
Christains aren’t “evil”, just fundamentally mistaken.
That is one of the fairest questions I have had from a believer (I assume that your subscription to this channel is valid evidence)
I don't feel that I am mean, certainly not compared to many on YT. But I accept that it may seem so.
I felt that any advocate of proselytising should not go unchallenged. There is no evidence for a god, let alone the biblical one. Therefore why peddle unjustified claim?
Do it right away.
This way they'd be warned you might turn up with an axe some night, going after them, 2 Chronicles 15:13 and Deuteronomy 13 style!...
grozde 3 months ago
@UrukEngineer I agree with your statements here too. Just that I think there is evidence to support belief in God. There's too many people that don't know what they believe, just taking on their family's traditions and assuming it as their own.
andrewccal 4 months ago
Yeah, I'd agree. Either way, it's a person's own worldview, and I'd prefer it if people openly listened to each others' POVs and didn't shove it down each others' throats.
I definitely have considered that I may be entirely wrong and that there is no God, nor gods. There's still the doubt in the back of my mind that says maybe I'm wrong, but every time I've entertained those thoughts, I've found too much evidence for a God to be convinced otherwise.
andrewccal 4 months ago
@andrewccal “just because the doctrine (or scientific theory) is not agreeable it may still be true” I whole heartedly agree. I hope that you can see that statement working both for and against any religious belief.
Would you be willing to consider that you might be wrong? There may be no god(s)?
UrukEngineer 4 months ago
@andrewccal Many people say they are Atheist (and put no caveat on it) because they just find their native religion unpleasant or illogical. Their Atheism is a reaction to religion. However when pressed they acknowledge that a human can’t know everything about everywhere, so the existence of a god(s) can’t be ruled out. Critically however, an Atheist’s position is that there is no evidence to support a belief in god(s).
UrukEngineer 4 months ago
@UrukEngineer I totally agree that Christians often apply these doctrines in horrible ways like picketing a gay person's funeral or justifying abuse of women's rights, but that doesn't make the fundamental doctrine false.
Also, if Christians need to recognize their worldview as an opinion, so should atheists. The core of an atheist's identity is that there is no God, something that can't be proven definitively either way. They are just mutually exclusive worldviews, not superior or inferior.
andrewccal 4 months ago
@UrukEngineer There are two issues here. 1) Historicity of the bible and ideas 2) Christian response to these ideas. There is evidence for Jesus'existence, resurrection, and the resulting movement that is connected to His claim to being God. That can be debated. However, just because the doctrine is not agreeable it may still be true. I don't like gravity, but I can't say it's wrong because I don't like it and it causes a lot of people hip fractures.
andrewccal 4 months ago
@andrewccal Christains however don't recognise their worldviews as "opinions", they form the core of their identity. Because they have "raised the stakes" in this way, ANY critism of their worldview is seen by them as a personal attack. I would rather they did not feel that way.
UrukEngineer 4 months ago
@andrewccal You are right, insulting one another gets us no where. I am, by nature, somewhat direct...but I hate rudeness.
The problem is that religious beliefs lack the evidence to place them on the same level as even tentative scientific theories. Therefore religious opinions should be open to robust scrutiny particularly as they support misogyny, homophobia and other unpleasant behaviour.
Christains aren’t “evil”, just fundamentally mistaken.
UrukEngineer 4 months ago
@andrewccal "Why do you have to be so mean?..."
That is one of the fairest questions I have had from a believer (I assume that your subscription to this channel is valid evidence)
I don't feel that I am mean, certainly not compared to many on YT. But I accept that it may seem so.
I felt that any advocate of proselytising should not go unchallenged. There is no evidence for a god, let alone the biblical one. Therefore why peddle unjustified claim?
UrukEngineer 4 months ago