Edwards Exploit
Top Comments
All Comments (100)
-
This is still in my top 5 thomas the tank engine episodes, i wish we would have gotten it here in RS US form. There is something with this episode here espically that shows one of Ringos Best Narrations, thats why i was happy when i was able to get this on UK VHS to finally legitly own a copy.
-
Boco shouldn't be at Tidmouth but I can understand why they did it. Boco didn't really get enough screen time, season 2 still focused too much on season 1 characters, and they can't always center the stories on branch lines and quarries. This way, at least season 2 acknowledged that he existed. unlike later seasons. Everything post season 4 just doesn't seem to cut it for me.
-
@BladeLight52 - Wait, call me stupid.
This counts as an accident? I thought this was a "high spirit."
Yeah. and I thought Toby was supposed to be accident-proof, too.
-
@51NAPA a bolt that holds siderods on I think
-
@MrJoeyWheeler Agreed, this is more of a breakdown than an accident.
Edward is the oldest engine of the entire team, and definitely the wisest, the most sensible and most level-headed, at least until HIT Entertainment got their hands on him and gave him a genuine accident and made him just old and a little scared of his age.
-
My view is that Edward didn't have an accident in this episode. Quoting Gordon in Off The Rails, I view it more as "High Spirits" which "might happen to any engine"
-
Best, not make more episodes like that!
-
@TheCustomechanic You're right about Boco, he shouldn't be at Tidmouth. But as for Duck, he did not have his branch line at this point, and was still working as a station pilot at Knapford.
-
@dizeesls4eva Yes. The originals and the books are so much better. My little brother prefers the old ones too; the CGI faces scare him.
I also agree with BladeLight. Edward's too careful and reliable to be derailed. It is, to quote Gordon, 'disgraceful.'
-
i´have a wish, an instrumental version of this episode
This is Edward's first accident ever.
I can't believe that HIT Entertainment gave Edward another accident. This time Edward was off the rails.
They broke one of the rules in the Railway series: Edward should never be derailed.
BladeLight52 2 years ago 50
When I watch this episode I always want to open the window and yell, "LOOK AT THIS, HIT ENTERTAINMENT! THIS IS WHAT THOMAS SHOULD BE LIKE!" This is the best episode EVER, but it always makes me sad thinking of the new episodes which are an insult to the Railway Series, in my opinion...
dizeesls4eva 3 years ago 36