Nicola Porpora - Polifemo "Alto Giove" Philippe Jaroussky
Loading...
44,742
Loading...
Uploader Comments (civileso)
Top Comments
-
Where's my life's fresh air and water?
.....Oh there he is! <3 :D Can't live without Jaroussky anymore!
see all
Video Responses
This video is a response to Nicola Porpora - Polifemo "Alto Giove" Arno Raunig
see all
All Comments (63)
-
Beautiful.
-
Magnificent!
-
Wonderfully beautiful!
-
hermoso!!!
-
@Erikk91 As for me, I don't want to read such stupid comments any more ! This aria is supposed to be sung by Polifemo, who was not a woman, and composed by Porpora for a male singer.
-
@inchesa1 cow get in your farm
-
@inchesa1 Is it you
-
@Erikk91 you are so so so idiot . non liket ?."FUCK YOU"
Loading...
This comment has received too many negative votes show
We want a woman to sing this. Not this stupid men
Erikk91 8 months ago
@Erikk91 Who are "we" Erik? As for me and many who watched this and other versions of this aria (which, by the way, was written for a man) don't feel the necessity to exclude male singers or make it mandatory to listen to it from a female singer. Not to mention that I never heard it (so far) sung by a woman singer, barring the only female version on YT, chopped off by a so-called soprano (schmoprano).
civileso 8 months ago 6
@civileso Ann Hallenberg sang this aria as a part of her Farinelli tour with Les Talens Lyriques. Somewhere on YouTube is the complete concert from the Festival of Baroque Music in Beaune, France.
OperaCurtainCalls 4 weeks ago
@OperaCurtainCalls Yes, I had seen that video. It was posted some time after my comment. I even remember searching a lot on YT to find a version by anyone... but could only find that amateur video. Then, like two weeks later, I saw Hallenberg's version recommended to me on my homepage. As you can see, I said "so far", not forever in my comment. Unlike Erikk91 here, I am not against anyone singing this, male or female. Heck, even I sing it. So why not PhJ or Hallenberg?
civileso 4 weeks ago